THE POLITICAL
CAMPAIGN OF 1864.
THE
PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION.--THE CLEVELAND CONVENTION.--THE CONVENTION AT BALTIMORE.--MR. LINCOLN'S RENOMINATION AND ACCEPTANCE.--POPULAR FEELING DURING THE SUMMER.--THE ARGUELLES
CASE.--THE FORGED PROCLAMATION.--THE NIAGARA FALLS CONFERENCE.
--THE CHICAGO CONVENTION.--PROGRESS AND RESULT OF THE CAMPAIGN.--POPULAR JOY AT THE RESULT.
THE American people were approaching another test of
their capacity for self-government, in some respects more
trying than any they had yet encountered. As the spring
of 1864 was passing away, the official term of President
Lincoln drew towards its close, and the people were required to choose his successor. At all times and under
the most favorable circumstances, the election of a President is attended with a degree of excitement, which some
of the wisest theorists have pronounced inconsistent with
the permanent harmony and safety of a republican form
of government. But that such an election should become
necessary in the midst of a civil war, which wrapped the
whole country in its flames and aroused such intense and
deadly passions in the public heart, was felt to be foremost among the calamities which had menaced the land.
The two great rebel armies still held the field. The
power of their government was still unbroken. All our
attempts to capture their capital had proved abortive.
The public debt was steadily and rapidly increasing.
Under the resistless pressure of military necessity, the Government, availing itself of the permissions of the Constitution, had suspended the great safeguard of civil freedom,
and dealt with individuals whom it deemed dangerous
to the public safety with as absolute and relentless
severity as the most absolute monarchies of Europe had
ever shown. Taxes were increasing; new drafts of men to fill the ranks
of new armies were impending; the Democratic party, from the very beginning hostile to the war
and largely imbued with devotion to the principle of
State Sovereignty on which the rebellion rested, and
with toleration for slavery out of which it grew, was
watching eagerly for every means of arousing popular
hatred against the Government, that they might secure its
transfer to their own hands; and the losses, the agonies,
the desolations of the war were beginning, apparently, to
make themselves felt injuriously upon the spirit, the endurance, the hopeful resolution of the people throughout
the loyal States.
That under these circumstances and amidst these elements of popular discontent and hostile passion, the
nation should be compelled to plunge into the whirlpool
of a political contest, was felt to be one of the terrible
necessities which might involve the nation's ruin. That
the nation went through it, with a majestic calmness up
to that time unknown, and came out from it stronger,
more resolute, and more thoroughly united than ever before, is among the marvels which confound all theory, and
demonstrate to the world the capacity of an intelligent
people to provide for every conceivable emergency in the
conduct of their own affairs.
Preparations for the nomination of candidates had be
gun to be made, as usual, early in the spring of 1864.
Some who saw most clearly the necessities of the future,
had for some months before expressed themselves strongly
in favor of the renomination of President Lincoln. But
this step was contested with great warmth and activity
by prominent members of the political party by which
he had been nominated and elected four years before.
Nearly all the original Abolitionists and many of the more
decidedly anti-slavery members of the Republican party
were dissatisfied, that Mr. Lincoln had not more rapidly
and more sweepingly enforced their extreme opinions.
Many distinguished public men resented his rejection of
their advice, and many more had been alienated by his
inability to recognize their claims to office. The most violent
opposition came from those who had been most
persistent and most clamorous in their exactions. And as
it was unavoidable that, in wielding so terrible and so
absolute a power in so terrible a crisis, vast multitudes
of active and ambitious men should be disappointed in
their expectations of position and personal gain, the
renomination of Mr. Lincoln was sure to be contested by
a powerful and organized effort.
At the very outset this movement acquired consistency
and strength by bringing forward the Hon. S. P. Chase,
Secretary of the Treasury, a man of great political boldness and experience, and who had prepared the way for
such a step by a careful dispensation of the vast patronage of his department, as the rival candidate. But it was
instinctively felt that this effort lacked the sympathy and
support of the great mass of the people, and it ended in
the withdrawal of his name as a candidate by Mr. Chase
himself.
The National Committee of the Union Republican party.
had called their convention, to be held at Baltimore, on
the 8th of June. This step had been taken from a conviction of the wisdom of terminating as speedily as
possible all controversy concerning candidates in the
ranks of Union men; and it was denounced with the
greatest vehemence by those who opposed Mr. Lincoln's
nomination, and desired more time to infuse their hostility
into the public mind. Failing to secure a postponement
of the convention, they next sought to overawe and dictate its action by a display of power, and the following
call was accordingly issued about the 1st of May, for a
convention to be held at Cleveland, Ohio, on the 31st day.
of that month:--
TO THE PEOPLE OF THE UNITED
STATES.
After having labored ineffectually to defer, as far
as was in our power,
the critical moment when the attention of the people must inevitably
be
fixed upon the selection of a candidate for the chief magistracy of
the
country; after having interrogated our conscience and consulted our
duty
as citizens, obeying at once the sentiment of a mature conviction
and a
profound affection for the common country, we feel ourselves
impelled,
on our own
responsibility, to declare to the people that the time has
come for all independent men, jealous of their liberties and of the
national
greatness, to confer together, and unite to resist the swelling
invasion of
an open, shameless, and unrestrained patronage, which threatens to
in gulf under its destructive wave the rights of the people, the
liberty and
dignity of the nation.
Deeply impressed with the conviction that, in a
time of revolution,
when the public attention is turned exclusively to the success of
armies,
and is consequently less vigilant of the public liberties, the
patronage
derived from the organization of an army of a million of men, and an
administration of affairs which seeks to control the remotest parts
of the
country in favor of its supreme chief, constitute a danger seriously
threatening the stability of republican institutions, we declare
that the
principle of one term, which has now acquired nearly the force of
law
by the consecration of time, ought to be inflexibly adhered to in
the approaching election.
We further declare, that we do not recognize in the
Baltimore Convention the essential conditions of a truly National Convention. Its
proximity to the centre of all the interested influences of the
administration, its
distance from the centre of the country, its mode of convocation,
the
corrupting practices to which it has been and inevitably will be
subjected, do not permit the people to assemble there with any expectation of being able to deliberate at full liberty. Convinced as we
are
that, in presence of the critical circumstances in which the nation
is
placed, it is only in the energy and good sense of the people that
the
general safety can be found; satisfied that the only way to consult
it is
to indicate a central position, to which every one may go without
too
much expenditure of means and time, and where the assembled people,
far from all administrative influence, may consult freely and
deliberate
peaceably, with the presence of the greatest possible number of men,
whose known principles guarantee their sincere and enlightened
devotion
to the rights of the people and to the preservation of the true
basis of
republican government,--we earnestly invite our fellow-citizens to
unite
at Cleveland, Ohio, on Tuesday, May 31, current, for consultation
and
concert of action in respect to the approaching Presidential
election.
Two other calls were issued after this, prominent
among the signers of which were some of the Germans
of Missouri and some of the old Radical Abolitionists of
the East.
The convention thus summoned met at the appointed
time, about one hundred and fifty in number. No call had
ever been put forward for the election of delegates to it,
and no one could tell whether its members represented any constituency
other than themselves. They came from
fifteen different States and the District of Columbia, but
every one knew that at the East the movement had no
strength whatever. An effort was made by some of
them to bring forward the name of General Grant as a
candidate, but the friends of Fremont formed altogether
too large a majority for that.
General John Cochrane, of New York, was chosen to
preside over the convention. In the afternoon the platform was presented, consisting of thirteen brief resolutions, favoring the suppression of the rebellion, the preservation of the habeas
corpus, of the right of asylum, and
the Monroe doctrine, recommending amendments of the
Constitution to prevent the re-establishment of slavery,
and to provide for the election of President and Vice-President for a single term only, and by the direct vote
of the people, and also urging the confiscation of the
lands of the rebels and their distribution among the soldiers and actual settlers.
The platform having been adopted, the convention proceeded to nominate General Fremont for President by
acclamation. General Cochrane was nominated for Vice-President. The title of "The Radical Democracy" was
chosen for the supporters of the ticket, a National Committee was appointed, and the convention adjourned.
General Fremont's letter of acceptance was dated June
4th. Its main scope was an attack upon Mr. Lincoln for
unfaithfulness to the principles he was elected to defend,
and upon his Administration for incapacity and selfishness,
and for what the writer called "its disregard of constitutional rights, its violation of personal liberty and the
liberty of the press, and, as a crowning shame, its abandonment of the right of asylum, dear to all free nations
abroad."
The platform he approved, with the exception of the
proposed confiscation. He intimated that if the Baltimore Convention would nominate any one but Mr. Lincoln he would not stand in the way of a union of all upon
that nominee; but said, "If Mr. Lincoln be renominated, as I believe it
would be fatal to the country to indorse a
policy and renew a power which has cost us the lives of
thousands of men and needlessly put the country on the
road to bankruptcy, there will remain no alternative but to
organize against him every element of conscientious opposition, with the view to prevent the misfortune of his
re-election." And he accepted the nomination, and announced that he had resigned his commission in the
army.
The convention, the nomination, and the letter of acceptance, fell dead upon the popular feeling. The time
had been when Fremont's name had power, especially
with the young men of the country. Many had felt that
he had received less than he deserved at the hands of
the Administration, and that if the opportunity had been
afforded he would have rendered to the country distinguished and valuable service. But the position which he
had here taken at once separated him from those who had
been his truest friends, whose feelings were accurately
expressed by Governor Morton, of Indiana, in a speech at
Indianapolis on the 12th of June, when he said: "I carried the standard of General Fremont to the best of my
poor ability through the canvass of 1856, and I have
since endeavored to sustain him, not only as a politician,
but as a military chieftain, and never until I read this
letter did I have occasion to regret what I have done. It
has been read with joy by his enemies and with pain by
his friends, and, omitting one or two sentences, there is
nothing in it that might not have been written or subscribed without inconsistency by Mr. Vallandigham."
The next form which the effort to prevent Mr. Lincoln's nomination and election took, was an effort to bring
forward General Grant as a candidate. A meeting had
been called for the 4th of June, in New York, ostensibly
to express the gratitude of the nation to him and the soldiers under his command, for their labors and successes.
As a matter of course the meeting was large and enthusiastic. President Lincoln wrote the following letter in
answer to an invitation to attend:--
EXECUTIVE MANSION, WASHINGTON, June 3,
1864.
Hon. F. A. CONKLING and others:
GENTLEMEN:--Your letter, inviting me to be present at a mass meeting of loyal citizens, to be held at New York, on the 4th instant,
for the purpose of expressing gratitude to Lieutenant-General Grant for
his signal services, was received yesterday. It is impossible for me to
attend. I approve, nevertheless, of whatever may tend to strengthen and
sustain General Grant and the noble armies now under his direction.
My previous high estimate of General Grant has been maintained and
heightened by what has occurred in the remarkable campaign he is now
conducting, while the magnitude and difficulty of the task before him
does not prove less than I expected. He and his brave soldiers are now
in the midst of their great trial, and I trust that at your meeting you
will so shape your good words that they may turn to men and guns,
moving to his and their support.
Whatever political purposes prompted the call for this
meeting, they were entirely overborne by the simple but
resistless appeal, made by the President in this letter, to
the patriotism of the country. Its effect was to stimulate
instantly and largely the effort to fill up the ranks of the
army, and thus aid General Grant in the great campaign
by which he hoped to end the war. In a private letter
to a personal friend, however, General Grant put a
decisive check upon all these attempts of politicians to
make his name the occasion of division among Union
men, by peremptorily refusing to allow himself to be
made a candidate, and by reiterating in still more emphatic
and hopeful terms the President's appeal to the people
for aid and support.
None of these schemes of ambitious aspirants to political leadership had any effect upon the settled sentiment
and purpose of the great body of the people. They
appreciated the importance of continuing the administration of the government in the same channel, and saw
clearly enough that nothing would more thoroughly
impress upon the rebels and the world the determination
of the people to preserve the Union at all hazards, and at
whatever cost, than the indorsement by a popular vote,
in spite of all mistakes and defects of policy, of the President, by
whom the war had thus far been conducted.
The nation, moreover, had entire faith in his integrity,
his sagacity, and his unselfish devotion to the public
good.
The Union and Republican Convention met at Baltimore on the day appointed, the 8th of June. It numbered
nearly five hundred delegates, chosen by the constituents
of each Congressional district of the loyal States, and by
the people in Tennessee, Louisiana, and Arkansas, in
which the rebel authority had been overthrown, and
who sought thus to renew their political relations with
the parties of the Union. The Rev. Robert J. Breckinridge, of Kentucky, was appointed temporary chairman,
and aroused the deepest enthusiasm of the convention
by his patriotic address on taking the chair. He proclaimed openly his hostility to slavery, and demanded, as
essential to the existence of the nation, the complete
overthrow of the rebellion, and condign punishment for
the traitors by whom it had been set on foot. In reference to the nomination of a presidential candidate, he
simply expressed the common sentiment when he said:--
Nothing can
be more plain than the fact that you are here as representatives of a great nation--voluntary representatives, chosen
with out forms of law, but as really representing the feelings and
principles,
and, if you choose, the prejudices of the American people, as if it
were
written in their laws and already passed by their votes. For the man
that you will nominate here for the Presidency of the United States
and
ruler of a great people, in a great crisis, is just as certain, I
suppose,
to become that ruler as any thing under heaven is certain before it
is
done. And moreover you will allow me to say, though perhaps it is
hardly strictly proper that I should, but as far as I know your opin ions, I suppose it is just as certain now, before you utter it,
whose name
you will utter--one which will be responded to from one end to the
other of this nation, as it will be after it has been uttered and
recorded
by your secretary."
The permanent organization was effected in the
afternoon, by the choice of Hon. William Dennison, Ex-Governor of Ohio, as president, with twenty-three vice-presidents, each from a different State, and twenty-three secretaries.
After a speech from Governor Dennison, and
another from Parson Brownlow, of Tennessee, the convention adjourned till Wednesday morning at nine
o'clock.
The first business which came up when the convention reassembled, was the report of the Committee on
Credentials. There were two important questions which
arose upon this report. The first was the Missouri question--there being a double delegation present from that
State. The committee had reported in favor of admitting
the delegation called the Radical Union Delegation to
seats in the convention, as the only one elected in conformity with usage and in regular form. An effort was
made to modify this by admitting both delegations to seats,
and allowing them to cast the vote of the State only in
case of their agreement. This proposition, however, was
voted down by a large majority, and the report of the
committee on that point was adopted. This result had
special importance in its bearing upon the vexed state of
politics in Missouri, which had hitherto, as we have seen,
caused Mr. Lincoln much trouble.
The next question, which had still greater importance,
related to the admission of the delegations from Tennessee,
Arkansas, and Louisiana. Congress had passed a resolution substantially excluding States which had been in rebellion from participation in national affairs until specifically readmitted to the Union--while it was known that
President Lincoln regarded all ordinances of secession as
simply null and void, incapable of affecting the legal relations of the States to the National Government. At the
very opening of the convention an effort had been made
by Hon. Thaddeus Stevens, of Pennsylvania, to secure
the adoption of a resolution against the admission of delegates from any States thus situated. This, however, had
failed, and the whole matter was referred to the Committee
on Credentials, of which Hon. Preston King, of New
York, had been appointed chairman. Mr. King, on behalf of this committee and under its instructions, reported
in favor of admitting these delegates to seats, but without giving them
the right to vote. Mr. King, for himself,
however, and as the only member of the committee who
dissented from its report, moved to amend it by giving
them equal rights in convention with delegates from the
other States. This amendment was adopted by a large
majority, and affected in a marked degree the subsequent
action of the convention. The report was further amended so as to admit delegates from the Territories of Colorado, Nebraska, and Nevada, and also from Florida and
Virginia, without the right to vote--and excluding a
delegation from South Carolina. Thus amended it was
adopted.
Mr. H. J. Raymond, of New York, as chairman of the
Committee on Resolutions, then reported the following
declaration of principles and policy for the Union and
Republican party:--
THE BALTIMORE
PLATFORM.
Resolved, That it is the highest duty of
every American citizen to
maintain, against all their enemies, the integrity of the Union and
the par amount authority of the Constitution and laws of the United States;
and
that, laying aside all differences of political opinion, we pledge
our selves as Union men, animated by a common sentiment and aiming at a
common object, to do every thing in our power to aid the Government
in quelling by force of arms the rebellion now raging against its
author ity, and in bringing to the punishment due to their crimes the
rebels and
traitors arrayed against it.
Resolved, That we approve the determination
of the Government of
the United States not to compromise with rebels, or to offer any
terms of
peace except such as may be based upon an unconditional surrender of
their hostility and a return to their just allegiance to the
Constitution
and laws of the United States; and that we call upon the Government
to maintain this position and to prosecute the war with the utmost
pos sible vigor to the complete suppression of the rebellion, in full
reliance
upon the self-sacrificing patriotism, the heroic valor, and the
undying
devotion of the American people to their country and its free
institutions.
Resolved, That as slavery was the cause and
now constitutes the
strength of this rebellion, and as it must be always and everywhere
hostile to the principles of republican government, justice and the
national
safety demand its utter and complete extirpation from the soil of
the
republic; and that while we uphold and maintain the acts and
proclamations by which the Government, in its own defence, has aimed
a death blow at this gigantic evil, we are in favor, furthermore, of such an
amendment to the Constitution, to be made by the people, in conformity with its provisions, as shall terminate and forever prohibit
the
existence of slavery within the limits or the jurisdiction of the
United
States.
Resolved, That the
thanks of the American people are due to the soldiers and sailors of the army and the navy, who have perilled their
lives
in defence of their country and in vindication of the honor of its
flag;
that the nation owes to them some permanent recognition of their
patriotism and their valor, and ample and permanent provision for those
of
their survivors who have received disabling and honorable wounds in
the
service of their country; and that the memories of those who have
fallen
in its defence shall be held in grateful and everlasting
remembrance.
Resolved, That we
approve and applaud the practical wisdom, the un selfish patriotism, and the unswerving fidelity to the Constitution
and the
principles of American liberty with which Abraham Lincoln has discharged, under circumstances of unparalleled difficulty, the great
duties
and responsibilities of the Presidential office; that we approve and
indorse, as demanded by the emergency and essential to the
preservation
of the nation, and as within the provisions of the Constitution, the
measures and acts which he has adopted to defend the nation against its
open
and secret foes; that we approve especially the Proclamation of
Emancipation and the employment as Union soldiers of men heretofore held
in slavery; and that we have full confidence in his determination to
carry
these and all other constitutional measures, essential to the
salvation of
the country, into full and complete effect.
Resolved, That we deem
it essential to the general welfare that harmony should prevail in our national councils, and we regard as
worthy
of public confidence and official trust those only who cordially
indorse
the principles proclaimed in these resolutions, and which should
characterize the administration of the Government.
Resolved, That the
Government owes to all men employed in its
armies, without regard to distinction of color, the full protection
of the
laws of war, and that any violation of these laws, or the usages of
civilized nations in time of war, by the rebels now in arms, should be
made
the subject of prompt and full redress.
Resolved, That the
foreign immigration which in the past has added so
much to the wealth, development of resources, and increase of power
of
this nation, the asylum of the oppressed of all nations, should be
fostered
and encouraged by a liberal and just policy.
Resolved, That we are in
favor of a speedy construction of the railroad
to the Pacific coast.
Resolved, That the
national faith, pledged for the redemption of the
public debt, must be kept inviolate, and that for this purpose we
recommend economy and rigid responsibility in the public expenditures,
and a vigorous and just system of taxation, and that it is the duty
of every loyal
State to sustain the credit and promote the use of the national
currency.
Resolved, That we approve the position
taken by the Government,
that the people of the United States can never regard with
indifference
the attempt of any European power to overthrow by force, or to
supplant
by fraud, the institutions of any republican government on the
Western
Continent; and that they will view with extreme jealousy, as
menacing
to the peace and independence of their own country, the efforts of
any
such power to obtain new footholds for monarchical governments, sustained by foreign military force, in near proximity to the United
States.
These resolutions were adopted unanimously and with
great enthusiasm. A motion was then made that Abraham Lincoln be nominated for re-election by acclamation,
but this was afterwards withdrawn, and a ballot taken
in the usual way; the only votes that were not given
for Mr. Lincoln were the twenty-two votes of Missouri,
which, as was explained by the chairman of the delegation, were given under positive instructions for General
Grant. Mr. Lincoln received four hundred and ninety-seven votes, and on motion of Mr. Hume, of Missouri, his
nomination was made unanimous, amid intense enthusiasm.
The contest over the Vice-Presidency was spirited
but brief. The candidates before the convention were
Vice-President Hamlin, Hon. D. S. Dickinson, of New
York, and Andrew Johnson, of Tennessee. The struggle lay however between Mr. Johnson and Mr. Dickinson.
The action of the Convention in admitting the delegates
from Tennessee to full membership had a powerful effect
in determining the result. Mr. Johnson received two
hundred votes on the first call of the States, and it being
manifest that he was to be the nominee, other States
changed, till the vote, when declared, stood four hundred
and ninety-two for Johnson, seventeen for Dickinson, and
nine for Hamlin.
The National Executive Committee was then appointed,
and the convention adjourned. On Thursday, June 9,
the committee appointed to inform Mr. Lincoln of his
nomination waited upon him at the White House. Governor Dennison, the President of the Convention and Chairman of the
Committee, addressed him as follows:--
MR.
PRESIDENT:--The National Union Convention, which closed its
sittings at Baltimore yesterday, appointed a committee, consisting
of one
from each State, with myself as chairman, to inform you of your
unanimous nomination by that convention for election to the officer of
President
of the United States. That committee, I have the honor of now
informing you, is present. On its behalf I have also the honor of
presenting you
with a copy of the resolutions or platform adopted by that
convention, as
expressive of its sense and of the sense of the loyal people of the
country
which it represents, of the principles and policy that should
characterize
the administration of the Government in the present condition of the
country. I need not say to you, sir, that the convention, in thus
unanimously nominating you for re-election, but gave utterance to the
almost
universal voice of the loyal people of the country. To doubt of your
triumphant election would be little short of abandoning the hope of
a final
suppression of the rebellion and the restoration of the government
over the
insurgent States. Neither the convention nor those represented by
that
body entertained any doubt as to the final result, under your
administration, sustained by the loyal people, and by our noble army and
gallant
navy. Neither did the convention, nor do this committee, doubt the
speedy suppression of this most wicked and unprovoked rebellion.
[A copy of the resolutions, which had been adopted,
was here handed
to the President.]
I would add, Mr. President, that it would be the
pleasure of the committee to communicate to you within a few days, through one of its
most
accomplished members, Mr. Curtis, of New York, by letter, more at
length
the circumstances under which you have been placed in nomination for
the Presidency.
The President said in response:--
MR. CHAIRMAN
AND GENTLEMEN OF THE COMMITTEE:--I will neither
conceal my gratification, nor restrain the expression of my
gratitude, that
the Union people, through their convention, in the continued effort
to
save and advance the nation, have deemed me not unworthy to remain
in
my present position. I know no reason to doubt that I shall accept
the
nomination tendered; and yet, perhaps, I should not declare
definitely
before reading and considering what is called the platform. I will
say
now, however, that I approve the declaration in favor of so amending
the
Constitution as to prohibit slavery throughout the nation. When the
people in revolt, with the hundred days' explicit notice that they
could
within those days resume their allegiance without the overthrow of
their
institutions, and that they could not resume it afterward, elected
to stand
out, such an amendment of the Constitution as is now proposed became
a fitting and necessary conclusion to the final success of the Union
cause.
Such alone can meet and cover all cavils. I now perceive its
importance
and embrace it. In the joint names of Liberty and Union let us labor
to
give it legal form and practical effect.
At the conclusion of the President's speech, all of the
committee shook him cordially by the hand and offered
their personal congratulations.
On the same afternoon a deputation from the National
Union League waited upon the President, and the chairman addressed him as follows:--
MR.
PRESIDENT:--I have the honor of introducing to you the representatives of the Union League of the Loyal States, to congratulate
you
upon your renomination, and to assure you that we will not fail at
the polls
to give you the support that your services in the past so highly
deserve.
We feel honored in doing this, for we are assured that we are aiding
in
re-electing to the proud position of President of the United States
one so
highly worthy of it--one among not the least of whose claims is that
he
was the emancipator of four millions of bondmen.
The President replied as follows:--
GENTLEMEN:--I
can only say in response to the remarks of your chair man, that I am very grateful for the renewed confidence which has
been
accorded to me, both by the convention and by the National League. I
am not insensible at all to the personal compliment there is in
this, yet I
do not allow myself to believe that any but a small portion of it is
to be
appropriated as a personal compliment to me. The convention and the
nation, I am assured, are alike animated by a higher view of the
interests of
the country, for the present and the great future, and the part I am
entitled
to appropriate as a compliment is only that part which I may lay
hold of as
being the opinion of the convention and of the League, that I am not
en tirely unworthy to be intrusted with the place I have occupied for
the
last three years. I have not permitted myself, gentlemen, to
conclude
that I am the best man in the country; but I am reminded in this
connection of a story of an old Dutch farmer, who remarked to a
companion
once that "it was not best to swap horses when crossing a stream."
On the evening of the same day the President was serenaded by the delegation from Ohio, and to them and
the large crowd which had gathered there, he made the
following brief speech:--
GENTLEMEN:--I
am very much obliged to you for this compliment. I
have just being saying, and will repeat it, that the hardest of all
speeches I have to answer is a serenade. I never know what to say on
these occasions. I suppose that you have done me this kindness in connection
with
the action of the Baltimore Convention, which has recently taken
place,
and with which, of course, I am very well satisfied. What we want
still
more than Baltimore Conventions, or Presidential elections, is
success
under General Grant. I propose that you constantly bear in mind that
the support you owe to the brave officers and soldiers in the field
is of the
very first importance, and we should therefore bend all our energies
to that
point. Now without detaining you any longer, I propose that you help
me
to close up what I am now saying with three rousing cheers for
General
Grant and the officers and soldiers under his command.
The rousing cheers were given--Mr. Lincoln himself
leading off, and waving his hat as earnestly as any one
present.
The written address of the Committee of the Convention
announcing his nomination, sent to him a few days afterwards, was as follows:--
NEW YORK, June 14,
1864.
Hon. ABRAHAM LINCOLN:
SIR:--The National Union Convention, which
assembled in Baltimore
on June 7th, 1864, has instructed us to inform you that you were
nominated with enthusiastic unanimity for the Presidency of the United
States
for four years from the 4th of March next.
The resolutions of the convention, which we have
already had the
pleasure of placing in your hands, are a full and clear statement of
the
principles which inspired its action, and which, as we believe, the
great
body of Union men in the country heartily approve. Whether those
resolutions express the national gratitude to our soldiers and
sailors, or
the national scorn of compromise with rebels, and consequent
dishonor,
or the patriotic duty of union and success; whether they approve the
Proclamation of Emancipation, the Constitutional Amendment, the employment of former slaves as Union soldiers, or the solemn
obligation of
the Government promptly to redress the wrongs of every soldier of
the
Union, of whatever color or race; whether they declare the
inviolability
of the plighted faith of the nation, or offer the national
hospitality to the
oppressed of every land, or urge the union by railroad of the
Atlantic and
Pacific Oceans; whether they recommend public economy and vigorous
taxation, or assert the fixed popular opposition to the
establishment by
armed force of foreign monarchies in the immediate neighborhood of
the
United States, or declare that those only are worthy of official
trust who
approve unreservedly the views and policy indicated in the
resolutions- they were equally hailed with the heartiness of profound conviction.
Believing with you, sir, that this is the people's
war for the maintenance
of a Government which you have justly described as "of the people,
by
the people, for the people," we are very sure that you will be glad to
know, not only from the resolutions themselves, but from the singular
harmony and enthusiasm with which they were adopted, how warm is
the popular welcome of every measure in the prosecution of the war
which is as vigorous, unmistakable, and unfaltering as the national purpose itself. No right, for instance, is so precious and sacred to the
American heart as that of personal liberty. Its violation is regarded
with just, instant, and universal jealousy. Yet, in this hour of peril,
every faithful citizen concedes that, for the sake of national existence
and
the common welfare, individual liberty may, as the Constitution provides
in case of rebellion, be sometimes summarily constrained, asking only
with painful anxiety that in every instance, and to the least detail,
that
absolute necessary power shall not be hastily or unwisely exercised.
We believe, sir, that the honest will of the Union men of the country
was never more truly represented than in this convention. Their purpose we believe to be the overthrow of armed rebels in the field, and
the
security of permanent peace and union, by liberty and justice, under the
Constitution. That these results are to be achieved amid cruel perplexities, they are fully aware. That they are to be reached only through
cordial unanimity of counsel, is undeniable. That good men may sometimes differ as to the means and the time, they know. That in the
conduct of all human affairs the highest duty is to determine, in the
angry conflict of passion, how much good may be practically accomplished, is their sincere persuasion. They have watched your official
course, therefore, with unflagging attention; and amid the bitter taunts
of eager friends and the fierce denunciation of enemies, now moving too
fast for some, now too slowly for others, they have seen you throughout
this tremendous contest patient, sagacious, faithful, just--leaning upon
the heart of the great mass of the people, and satisfied to be moved by
its
mighty pulsations.
It is for this reason that, long before the convention met, the popular
instinct indicated you as its candidate; and the convention, therefore,
merely recorded the popular will. Your character and career prove
your unswerving fidelity to the cardinal principles of American liberty
and of the American Constitution. In the name of that liberty and Constitution, sir, we earnestly request your acceptance of this nomination;
reverently commending our beloved country, and you, its Chief Magistrate, with all its brave sons who, on sea and land, are faithfully
defending the good old American cause of equal rights, to the blessing of
Almighty God.
We are, sir, very respectfully, your friends and fellow-citizens.
WM. DENNISON, O.,
Chairman. |
W. BUSHNELL, Ill. |
JOSIAH DRUMMOND,
Maine. |
L. P. ALEXANDER, Mich. |
THOS. E. SAWYER,
N. H. |
A. W. RANDALL, Wis. |
BRADLEY BARLOW,
Vt. |
A. OLIVER, Iowa. |
A.
H. BULLOCK, Mass. |
THOMAS SIMPSON, Minn. |
A.
M. GAMMELL, R. I. |
JOHN BIDWELL, Cal. |
C.
S. BUSHNELL, Conn. |
THOMAS H. PEARNE, Oregon |
G.
W. CURTIS, N. Y. |
LEROY KRAMER, West Va. |
W.
A. NEWELL, N. J. |
A. C. WILDER, Kansas. |
HENRY JOHNSON, Penn. |
M. M. BRIEN, Tennessee. |
N.
B. SMITHERS, Del. |
J. P. GREVES, Nevada. |
W.
L. W. SEABROOK, Md. |
A. A. ATOCHA, La. |
JOHN F. HUME, Mo. |
A. S. PADDOCK, Nebraska. |
G.
W. HITE, Ky. |
VALENTINE DELL, Arkansas. |
E.
P. TYFFE, Ohio. |
JOHN A. NYE, Colorado. |
CYRUS M. ALLEN, Ind. |
A. B. SLOANAKER, Utah. |
REPLY OF MR. LINCOLN.
EXECUTIVE MANSION,
WASHINGTON, June 27,
1864.
HON. WM. DENNISON and others, a Committee of the
Union National Convention:
GENTLEMEN:--Your letter of the 14th inst., formally
notifying me that
I have been nominated by the convention you represent for the Presidency of the United States for four years from the 4th of March
next, has
been received. The nomination is gratefully accepted, as the
resolutions
of the convention, called the platform, are heartily approved.
While the resolution in regard to the supplanting
of republican government upon the Western Continent is fully concurred in, there might
be
misunderstanding were I not to say that the position of the
Government
in relation to the action of France in Mexico, as assumed through
the
State Department and indorsed by the convention among the measures
and acts of the Executive, will be faithfully maintained so long as
the
state of facts shall leave that position pertinent and applicable.
I am especially gratified that the soldier and
seaman were not forgotten
by the convention, as they forever must and will be remembered by
the
grateful country for whose salvation they devote their lives.
Thanking you for the kind and complimentary terms
in which you
have communicated the nomination and other proceedings of the convention, I subscribe myself,
Your obedient servant,
ABRAHAM LINCOLN.
The platform adopted by the Baltimore Convention
met with the general approval of those of the people who
claimed to be the supporters of the Government. One
exception was, however, found in the person of Mr.
Charles Gibson, Solicitor of the United States in the Court of Claims at
St. Louis, who, considering, as he
said, that that platform rendered his retention of office
under Mr. Lincoln's Administration wholly useless to the
country, as well as inconsistent with his principles, tendered his resignation, through the clerk of the Court of
Claims, Mr. Welling.
The President's reply, communicated through his private secretary, was
as follows:--
EXECUTIVE MANSION, WASHINGTON, July 25,1864.
J. C. WELLING, ESQ.:--
According to the request contained in your note, I
have placed Mr.
Gibson's letter of resignation in the hands of the President. He has
read the letter, and says he accepts the resignation, as he will be
glad to
do with any other, which may be tendered, as this is, for the
purpose of
taking an attitude of hostility against him.
He says he was not aware that he was so much
indebted to Mr. Gibson
for having accepted the office at first, not remembering that he
ever
pressed him to do so, or that he gave it otherwise than as usual,
upon a
request made on behalf of Mr. Gibson.
He thanks Mr. Gibson for his acknowledgment that he
has been treated
with personal kindness and consideration, and he says he knows of
but
two small drawbacks upon Mr. Gibson's right to still receive such
treatment, one of which is that he could never learn of his giving much
attention to the duties of his office, and the other is this studied
attempt
of Mr. Gibson's to stab him.
I am, very truly,
Your obedient servant,
JOHN HAY.
The elements of opposition to Mr. Lincoln's election in
the ranks of his own party were checked, though not
wholly destroyed, by the unanimity of his nomination.
Conferences were still held among prominent men, especially in the city of New York, for the purpose of organizing this hostility and making it effective, and a call was
put in circulation for a convention to be held at Cincinnati, to put in nomination another candidate. The movement, however, was so utterly destitute of popular sympathy that it was soon abandoned. A very sharp and
acrimonious warfare was still waged upon Mr. Lincoln
and his Administration not only by the leading presses
of the opposition, but by prominent men and influential journals
ostensibly in the ranks of his supporters. Every
act of the government was canvassed with eager and unfriendly scrutiny, and made, wherever it was possible, the
ground of hostile assault.
Among the matters thus seized upon was the surrender to the Spanish authorities of a Cuban named
Arguelles, which was referred to by the Fremont Convention as a denial of the right of asylum. This man,
Don Jose Augustine Arguelles, was a colonel in the
Spanish army, and Lieutenant-Governor of the District
of Colon, in Cuba. As such, in November, 1863, he
effected the capture of a large number of slaves that were
landed within his district, and received from the Government of Cuba praise for his efficiency, and the sum of
fifteen thousand dollars for his share of prize-money on
the capture. Shortly afterwards, he obtained leave of
absence for twenty days, for the purpose of going to New
York and there making the purchase of the Spanish
newspaper called La
Cronica. He came to New York,
and there remained. In March following, the Cuban
Government made application to our authorities, through
the Consul-General's office at Havana, stating that it had
been discovered that Arguelles, with others, had been
guilty of the crime of selling one hundred and forty-one
of the cargo of negroes thus captured, into slavery, and
by means of forged papers representing to the Government that they had died after being landed; stating also
that his return to Cuba was necessary to procure the
liberation of his hapless victims, and desiring to know
whether the Government of the United States would
cause him to be returned to Cuba. Documents authenticating the facts of the case were forwarded to our
authorities. There being no extradition treaty between
our country and Spain, the Cuban Government could
take no proceedings before the courts in the matter,
and the only question was whether our Government
would take the responsibility of arresting Arguelles and
sending him back or not. The Government determined
to assume the responsibility, and sent word to the Cuban authorities
that if they would send a suitable officer to
New York, measures would be taken to place Arguelles
in his charge. The officer was sent, and Arguelles having been arrested by the United States Marshal at
New York, was, before any steps could be taken to
appeal to any of the courts on his behalf, put on board a
steamer bound for Havana. This proceeding caused
great indignation until the facts were understood. Arguelles having money, had found zealous friends in
New York, and a strong effort was made in his favor.
It was stated on his behalf that, instead of being
guilty of selling these negroes into slavery, it was the
desire of the Cuban authorities to get possession of him
and silence him, lest he should publish facts within his
knowledge which implicated the authorities themselves
in that nefarious traffic. And the fact that he was taken
as he was, by direct order of the Government, not by any
legal or judicial proceedings, and without having the
opportunity to test before the courts the right of the
Government thus to send back any one, however criminal,
was alleged to spring from the same disregard of liberty
and law in which the arbitrary arrests which had been
made of rebel sympathizers were said to have had their
source. Proceedings were even taken against the United
States Marshal under a statute of the State of New York
against kidnapping, and everywhere the enemies of the
Administration found in the Arguelles case material for
assailing it as having trampled upon the right of asylum,
exceeded its own legal powers, insulted the laws and
courts of the land, and endangered the liberties of the
citizen; while the fact of its having aided in the punishment of an atrocious crime, a crime intimately connected
with the slave-trade, so abhorrent to the sympathies of
the people, was kept out of sight.
Another incident used to feed the public distrust of
the Administration, was the temporary suppression of
two Democratic newspapers in the city of New York.
On Wednesday, May 18th, these two papers, the World
and the Journal of
Commerce, published what purported to be a proclamation of President
Lincoln. At this time,
as will be recollected, General Grant was still struggling
with Lee before Spottsylvania, with terrible slaughter
and doubtful prospects, while Sigel had been driven
back by Imboden, and Butler was held in check by
Beauregard. This proclamation announced to the country that General Grant's campaign was virtually closed;
and, "in view of the situation in Virginia, the disaster at
Red River, the delay at Charleston, and the general state
of the country," it appointed the 26th of May as a day
of fasting, humiliation, and prayer, and ordered a fresh
draft of four hundred thousand men. The morning of its
publication was the day of the departure of the mails for
Europe. Before its character was discovered, this forged
proclamation, telegraphed all over the country, had
raised the price of gold five or six per cent., and carried discouragement and dismay to the popular heart.
The suppression of the papers by which it had been
published, the emphatic denial of its authenticity, and
the prompt adoption of measures to detect its author,
speedily reassured the public mind. After being satisfied that the publication of the document was inadvertent, the journals seized were permitted to resume publication, the authors of the forgery were sent to Fort
Lafayette, and public affairs resumed their ordinary
course.
But the action of the Government gave fresh stimulus
to the partisan warfare upon it. As in the Arguelles case
and the arbitrary arrests it had been charged with trampling upon the liberties of the citizen, so now it was charged
with attacking the liberty of the press. Governor
Seymour directed the District Attorney of New York to
take measures for the prosecution and punishment of all
who had been connected with shutting up the newspaper
offices. The matter was brought before a grand-jury,
which reported that it was inexpedient to examine into
the subject."
Determined not to be thus thwarted, Governor Seymour, alleging that the grand-jury had disregarded their oaths, directed
the District Attorney to bring the subject
before some magistrate. Warrants were accordingly
issued by City Judge Russell for the arrest of General
Dix and the officers who had acted in the matter. The
parties voluntarily appeared before the judge, and an
argument of the legal questions involved was had. The
judge determined to hold General Dix and the rest for
the action of the grand-jury. One grand-jury, however,
had already refused to meddle with the matter, and,
greatly to the disappointment of those who had aimed
to place the State of New York in a position of open
hostility to the Government of the United States, no further proceedings were ever taken in the matter.
An effort was made to bring the subject up in Congress. Among other propositions, Mr. Brooks, of New
York, proposed to add, as an amendment to a bill for
the incorporation of a Newsboys' Home in the District of
Columbia, a provision that no newspaper should be suppressed in Washington, or its editor incarcerated, without
due process of law. He succeeded in making a speech
abounding in denunciations of the Government, but had
no other success.
To those men at the North who really sympathized with
the South on the slavery question, the whole policy of
the Administration upon that subject was distasteful.
The Emancipation Proclamation, the repeal of the Fugitive Slave Law, and even the employment of negroes in
the army, were with them grave causes of complaint
against it. The President's views on this matter were
expressed in the following conversational remarks, to some
prominent Western gentlemen:--
The slightest
knowledge of arithmetic (said he) will prove to any
man that the rebel armies cannot be destroyed by Democratic
strategy.
It would sacrifice all the white men of the North to do it. There
are
now in the service of the United States nearly two hundred thousand
able-bodied colored men, most of them under arms, defending and ac quiring Union territory. The Democratic strategy demands that these
forces be disbanded, and that the masters be conciliated by
restoring them
to slavery. The black men who now assist Union prisoners to escape
are to be converted into our enemies, in the vain hope of gaining
the
good-will of their masters. We shall have to fight two nations
instead
of one.
You cannot conciliate the South if you guarantee to
them ultimate
success, and the experience of the present war proves their success
is
inevitable if you fling the compulsory labor of four millions of
black men
into their side of the scale. Will you give our enemies such
military
advantages as insure success, and then depend upon coaxing,
flattery, and
concession to get them back into the Union? Abandon all the forts
now
garrisoned by black men, take two hundred thousand men from our
side,
and put them in the battle-field, or cornfield, against us, and we
would
be compelled to abandon the war in three weeks.
We have to hold territory in inclement and sickly
places. Where are
the Democrats to do this? It was a free fight, and the field was
open to
the War Democrats to put down this rebellion by fighting against
both
master and slave long before the present policy was inaugurated.
There
have been men base enough to propose to me to return to slavery our
black warriors of Port Hudson and Olustee, and thus win the respect
of
the masters they fought. Should I do so, I should deserve to be
damned
in time and eternity. Come what will, I will keep my faith with
friend and
foe. My enemies pretend I am now carrying on this war for the sole
purpose of abolition. So long as I am President it shall be carried
on
for the sole purpose of restoring the Union. But no human power can
subdue this rebellion without the use of the emancipation policy,
and
every other policy calculated to weaken the moral and physical
forces of
the rebellion.
Freedom has given us two hundred thousand men,
raised on Southern
soil. It will give us more yet. Just so much it has abstracted from
the
enemy; and instead of checking the South, there are evidences of a
fraternal feeling growing up between our men and the rank and file of
the
rebel soldiers. Let my enemies prove to the country that the
destruction
of slavery is not necessary to the restoration of the Union. I will
abide
the issue.
Aside from the special causes of attack which we have
mentioned, others were brought forward more general in
their character. The burdens of the war were made
especially prominent. Every thing discouraging was
harped upon and magnified, every advantage was belittled
and sneered at. The call for five hundred thousand men
in June was even deprecated by the friends of the Administration, because of the political capital which its
enemies would be sure to make of it. Nor was Mr. Lincoln himself unaware that such would be the result, but, though
recognizing the elements of dissatisfaction which
it carried with it, he did not suffer himself to be turned
aside in the least from the path which duty to his coutry required him to pursue. The men were needed, he
said, and must be had, and should he fail as a candidate.
for re-election in consequence of doing his duty to the
country, he would have at least the satisfaction of going
down with colors flying.
Financial difficulties were also used in the same way.
The gradual rise in the price of gold was pointed at as
indicating the approach of that financial ruin which
was surely awaiting the country, if the re-election of Mr.
Lincoln should mark the determination of the people to
pursue the course upon which they had entered.
Amidst these assaults from his opponents, Mr. Lincoln
seemed fairly entitled, at least, to the hearty support of
all the members of his own party. And yet this very
time was chosen by Senator Wade, of Ohio, and H.
Winter Davis, of Maryland, to make a violent attack upon
him for the course which he had pursued in reference
to the Reconstruction Bill, which he had not signed, but
had given his reasons for not signing, in his proclamation of July 18th. They charged him with usurpation,
with presuming upon the forbearance of his supporters,
with defeating the will of the people by an Executive
perversion of the Constitution, &c., &c., and closed a
long and violent attack by saying that if he wished their
support he "must confine himself to his Executive
duties--to obey and execute, not make the laws--to suppress by arms armed rebellion, and leave political reorganization to Congress."
This manifesto, prepared with marked ability, and
skilfully adapted to the purpose it was intended to serve,
at first created some slight apprehension among the supporters of the President. But it was very soon felt that
it met with no response from the popular heart, and it
only served to give a momentary buoyancy to the hopes
of the Opposition.
Still another incident soon occurred to excite a considerable degree of
public anxiety concerning the immediate political future. It was
universally understood that a strong desire for peace pervaded the
public mind, and. that the determination to prosecute the war was
the dictate of duty, rather than inclination. To such an extent
did this longing for peace influence the sentiments and action of
some, among the least resolute and hopeful of the political
leaders in the Republican party, that ready access to them was
found by agents of the Rebel Government, stationed in Canada for such active service as circumstances might require. Of these agents, who were
then at Niagara Falls, were C. C. Clay, formerly United
States Senator from Alabama, Professor Holcombe, of Virginia, and George N. Sanders. Acting on their behalf
and under their instructions, W. Cornell Jewett, an irresponsible and half-insane adventurer, had put himself in
communication with Hon. Horace Greeley, Editor of the
New York Tribune, whose intense eagerness for peace had
already commended him to the admiration and sympathy
of the emissaries of the Rebel Government. In reply to
some letter which had been addressed to him, but which
has not yet been made public, Jewett wrote on the 5th of
July to Mr. Greeley the following letter:--
NIAGARA FALLS, July 5,
1864.
MY DEAR MR. GREELEY:--In reply to your note, I have
to advise having just left Hon. George N. Sanders, of Kentucky, on the Canada
side. I
am authorized to state to you, for our use only, not the public,
that two
ambassadors of Davis & Co. are now in Canada, with full and complete
powers for a peace, and Mr. Sanders requests that you come on
immediately to me, at Cataract House, to have a private interview, or if
you
will send the President's protection for
him and two friends, they will
come on and meet you. He says the whole matter can be consummated
by me, you, them, and President Lincoln. Telegraph me in such form
that I may know if you come here, or they to come on with me.
The next day Mr. Jewett also telegraphed as follows:--
H. GREELEY, Tribune:
Will you come here? Parties have full power. Wrote
you yesterday
JEWETT.
This letter and telegram Mr. Greeley enclosed to the
President, at Washington, accompanied by the following letter:--
NEW YORK, July 7,
1864.MY DEAR SIR:--I venture to enclose you a letter and telegraphic
dis patch that I received yesterday from our irrepressible friend,
Colorado
Jewett, at Niagara Falls. I think they deserve attention. Of course
I
do not indorse Jewett's positive averment that his friends at the
Falls
have "full powers" from J. D., though I do not doubt that he thinks
they have. I let that statement stand as simply evidencing the
anxiety
of the Confederates everywhere for peace. So much is beyond
doubt. And therefore I venture to remind you that our bleeding,
bankrupt,
almost dying country also longs for peace--shudders at the prospect
of
fresh conscriptions, of further wholesale devastations, and of new
rivers
of human blood; and a wide-spread conviction that the Government and
its prominent supporters are not anxious for peace, and do not
improve
proffered opportunities to achieve it, is doing great harm now, and
is
morally certain, unless removed, to do far greater in the
approaching
elections. It is not enough that we anxiously desire a true and
lasting peace; we
ought to demonstrate and establish the truth beyond cavil. The fact
that
A. H. Stephens was not permitted a year ago to visit and confer with
the authorities at Washington has done harm, which the tone at the
late
National Convention at Baltimore is not calculated to counteract. I
entreat you, in your own time and manner, to submit overtures for
pacification to the Southern insurgents, which the impartial must
pronounce frank and generous. If only with a view to the momentous election soon to occur in North Carolina, and of the draft to be
enforced in
the Free States, this should be done at once. I would give the
safe-con duct required by the rebel envoys at Niagara, upon their parole to
avoid
observation and to refrain from all communication with their sympathizers in the loyal States; but you may see reasons for declining
it. But
whether through them or otherwise, do not, I entreat you, fail to
make
the Southern people comprehend that you, and all of us, are anxious
for
peace, and prepared to grant liberal terms. I venture to suggest the
following PLAN OF ADJUSTMENT.
1. |
The Union is
restored and declared perpetual. |
2. |
Slavery is
utterly and forever abolished throughout the same. |
3. |
A complete
amnesty for all political offences, with a restoration of all
the inhabitants of each State to all the privileges of
citizens of the United
States. |
4. |
The Union to
pay four hundred million dollars ($400,000,000) in five
per cent. United States stock to the late Slave States,
loyal and secession
alike, to be apportioned pro
rata,
according to their slave population respectively, by the
census of 1860, in compensation for the losses of their
loyal citizens by the abolition of slavery. Each State to be
entitled to its quota upon the ratification by its
legislature of this adjustment. The bonds to be at the
absolute disposal of the legislature aforesaid. |
5. |
The said Slave
States to be entitled henceforth to representation in the
House on the basis of their total, instead of their federal
population, the
whole now being free. |
6. |
A national
convention, to be assembled so soon as may be, to ratify this
adjustment, and make such changes in the Constitution as may
bedeemed advisable. |
Mr.
President, I fear you do not realize how intently the people desire
any peace consistent with the national integrity and honor, and how
joyously they would hail its achievement, and bless its authors.
With
United States stocks worth but forty cents in gold per dollar, and
drafting about to commence on the third million of Union soldiers, can
this
be wondered at?
I do not say that a just peace is now attainable,
though I believe it to
be so. But I do say that a frank offer by you to the insurgents of
terms
which the impartial say ought to be accepted will, at the worst,
prove
an immense and sorely needed advantage to the national cause. It may
save us from a Northern insurrection.
Yours,
truly, |
HORACE GREELEY. |
Hon. A. LINCOLN, President, Washington,
D. C.
P. S.--Even though it should be deemed unadvisable
to make an offer
of terms to the rebels, I insist that, in any possible case, it is
desirable
that any offer they may be disposed to make should be received, and
either accepted or rejected. I beg you to invite those now at
Niagara to
exhibit their credentials and submit their ultimatum. H. G.
To this letter the President sent the following answer:--
WASHINGTON, D. C., July 9,
1864.
Hon. HORACE GREELEY:
DEAR SIR:--Your letter of the 7th, with enclosures,
received. If you
can find any person anywhere professing to have any proposition of
Jefferson Davis, in writing, for peace, embracing the restoration of
the
Union and abandonment of slavery, whatever else it embraces, say to
him he may come to me with you, and that if he really brings such
prop osition, he shall, at the least, have safe-conduct with the paper
(and with out publicity if he chooses) to the point where you shall have met
him.
The same if there be two or more persons.
Mr. Greeley answered this letter as follows:--
OFFICE OF THE
TRIBUNE, NEW YORK, July 10,
1864.
MY DEAR SIR:--I have yours of yesterday. Whether
there be persons
at Niagara (or elsewhere) who are empowered to commit the rebels by
negotiation, is a question; but if there
be such, there is no question at all
that they would decline to exhibit their credentials to me, much
more to
open their budget and give me their best terms. Green as I may be, I
am
not quite so verdant as to imagine any thing of the sort. I have
neither
purpose nor desire to be made a confidant, far less an agent, in
such negotiations. But I do deeply realize that the rebel chiefs achieved a
most
decided advantage in proposing or pretending to propose to have A.
H.
Stephens visit Washington as a peacemaker, and being rudely
repulsed;
and I am anxious that the ground lost to the national cause by that
mistake shall somehow be regained in season for effect on the
approaching
North Carolina election. I will see if I can get a look into the
hand of
whomsoever may be at Niagara; though that is a project so manifestly
hopeless that I have little heart for it, still I shall try.
Meantime I wish you would consider the propriety of
somehow apprising the people of the South, especially those of North Carolina,
that
no overture or advance looking to peace and reunion has ever been
repelled by you, but that such a one would at. any time have been
cordially
received and favorably regarded, and would still be.
Hon. A.
LINCOLN.
This letter failed to reach the President until after the
following one was received, and was never, therefore,
specifically answered.
Three days after the above letter, Mr. Greeley, having
received additional information from some quarter, wrote
to the President again as follows:--
OFFICE OF THE
TRIBUNE, NEW YORK, July 13,
1864.
MY DEAR SIR:--I have now information on which I can
rely that two
persons duly commissioned and empowered to negotiate for peace are
at
this moment not far from Niagara Falls, in Canada, and are desirous
of
conferring with yourself, or with such persons as you may appoint
and
empower to treat with them. Their names (only given in confidence)
are
Hon. Clement O. Clay, of Alabama, and Hon. Jacob Thompson, of
Mississippi. If you should prefer to meet them in person, they require
safe-con ducts for themselves, and for George N. Sanders, who will accompany
them. Should you choose to empower one or more persons to treat with
them in Canada, they will of course need no safe-conduct; but they
can not be expected to exhibit credentials save to commissioners
empowered
as they are. In negotiating directly with yourself, all grounds of
cavil would be avoided, and you would be enabled at all times to act
upon the
freshest advices of the military situation. You will of course
understand
that I know nothing and have proposed nothing as to terms, and that
nothing is conceded or taken for granted by the meeting of persons
empowered to negotiate for peace. All that is assumed is a mutual
desire
to terminate this wholesale slaughter, if a basis of adjustment can
be mutually agreed on, and it seems to me high time that an effort to
this end
should be made. I am of course quite other than sanguine that a
peace
can now be made, but I am quite sure that a frank, earnest, anxious
effort to terminate the war on honorable terms would immensely
strengthen the Government in case of its failure, and would help us
in the
eyes of the civilized world, which now accuses us of obstinacy, and
indisposition even to seek a
peaceful solution of our sanguinary, devastating
conflict. Hoping to hear that you have resolved to act in the
premises,
and to act so promptly that a good influence may even yet be exerted
on
the North Carolina election next month,
I remain
yours, |
HORACE GREELEY. |
Hon. A. LINCOLN, Washington.
On the 12th, the day before the foregoing letter was
sent, Mr. George N. Sanders had written to Mr. Greeley
as follows:--
CLIFTON
HOUSE, NIAGARA FALLS,
CANADA WEST, July 12,
1864.
DEAR SIR:--I
am authorized to say that Honorable Clement C. Clay,
of Alabama, Professor James P. Holcombe, of Virginia, and George N.
Sanders, of Dixie, are ready and willing to go at once to
Washington,
upon complete and unqualified protection being given either by the
President or Secretary of War. Let the permission include the three names
and one other.
Very respectfully, |
GEORGE N. SANDERS. |
To Hon.
HORACE GREELEY.
This letter of Mr. Sanders does not seem to have been
communicated to the President, but on the receipt of Mr.
Greeley's letter of the 13th, he immediately answered it
by the following telegram:--
EXECUTIVE MANSION, WASHINGTON, July 15,
1864.
HON. HORACE GREELEY, New York:--I suppose you
received my letter
of the 9th. I have just received yours of the 13th, and am
disappointed
by it. I was not expecting you to send me
a letter, but to bring me a
man, or men. Mr. Hay goes to you with my answer to yours of the
13th.
A. LINCOLN.
The answer which Major Hay carried was as follows:--
EXECUTIVE
MANSION, WASHINGTON, July 15,
1864.
Hon. HORACE GREELEY:
MY DEAR SIR:--Yours of the 13th is just received,
and I am disappointed that you have not already reached here with those commisioners. If they would consent to come, on being shown my letter to you
of
the 9th instant, show that and this to them, and if they will come
on the
terms stated in the former, bring them. I not only intend a sincere
effort
for peace, but I intend that you shall be a personal witness that it
is
made.
When Major Hay arrived at New York, he delivered
to Mr. Greeley this letter from the President, and telegraphed its result to the President as follows:--
UNITED STATES MILITARY
TELEGRAPH,
WAR DEPARTMENT, NEW YORK, 9 A.M., July 16,
1864.
His
Excellency A. LINCOLN,
President of the United States:
Arrived this morning at 6 A.M., and delivered your
letter few minutes
after. Although he thinks some one less known would create less excitement and be less embarrassed by public curiosity, still he will
start
immediately if he can have an absolute safe-conduct for four persons
to
be named by him. Your letter he does not think will guard them from
arrest, and with only those letters he would have to explain the
whole
matter to any officer who might choose to hinder them. If this meets
with your approbation, I can write the order in your name as A.
A.-G.
or you can send it by mail. Please answer me at Astor House.
JOHN HAY, A.
A.-G.
The President at once answered by telegraph as follows:--
EXECUTIVE, MANSION,
WASHINGTON, July 16,
1864.
JOHN HAY, Astor House, New York:
Yours received. Write the safe-conduct as you
propose, without wait ing for one by mail from me. If there is or is not any thing in the
affair,
I wish to know it without unnecessary delay. A. LINCOLN.
Major Hay accordingly wrote the following safe-conduct,
armed with which Mr. Greeley betook himself at once to
Niagara Falls:--
EXECUTIVE MANSION, WASHINGTON,
D. C. The President of the United States directs that the four
persons whose
names follow, to wit:
|
HON. CLEMENT
C. CLAY, |
|
HON. JACOB
THOMPSON, |
|
Prof. JAMES
B. HOLCOMBE, |
|
GEORGE N.
SANDERS, |
shall have
safe-conduct to the City of Washington in company with the
Hon. Horace Greeley, and shall be exempt from arrest or annoyance of
any kind from any officer of the United States during their journey
to the
said City of Washington.
By order of the President:
JOHN HAY, Major
and A. A.-G.
On his arrival, Mr. Greeley sent. by the hands of Mr.
Jewett the following letter:--
NIAGARA FALLS, N. Y., July 17,
1864.
GENTLEMEN:--I am informed that you are duly
accredited from Richmond as the bearers of propositions looking to the establishment of
peace;
that you desire to visit Washington in the fulfilment of your
mission; and
that you further desire that Mr. George N. Sanders shall accompany
you.
If my information be thus far substantially correct, I am authorized
by
the President of the United States to tender you his safe-conduct on
the
journey proposed, and to accompany you at the earliest time that
will be
agreeable to you. I have the honor to be, gentlemen,
Yours, HORACE GREELEY.
To Messrs.
CLEMENT C. CLAY, JACOB THOMPSON, JAMES P. HOLCOMBE,
Clifton House, C. W.
To this letter the following reply was returned:--
CLIFTON HOUSE, NIAGARA FALLS, July 18,
1864.
SIR:--We have the honor to acknowledge your favor
of the 17th inst.,
which would have been answered on yesterday, but for the absence of
Mr. Clay. The safe-conduct of the President of the United States has
been tendered us, we regret to state, under some misapprehension of
facts.
We have not been accredited to him from Richmond, as the bearers of
propositions looking to the establishment of peace. We are, however,
in the confidential employment of our Government, and are entirely
familiar with its wishes and opinions on that subject; and we feel
authorized to declare, that if the circumstances disclosed in this
correspondence
were communicated to Richmond, we would be at once invested with
the authority to which your letter refers, or other gentlemen,
clothed
with full powers, would be immediately sent to Washington with a
view
of hastening a consummation so much to be desired, and terminating
at
the earliest possible moment the calamities of the war. We
respectfully
solicit, through your intervention, a safe-conduct to Washington,
and
thence by any route which may be designated through your lines to
Richmond. We would be gratified if Mr. George Sanders was embraced
in this privilege. Permit us, in conclusion, to acknowledge our
obligations to you for the interest you have manifested in the furtherance
of our wishes, and to express the hope that, in any event, you will
afford us
the opportunity of tendering them in person before you leave the
Falls.
We remain, very respectfully, &c.,
C. C. CLAY, JR.
J. P. HOLCOMBE.
P. S.--It is proper to state that Mr. Thompson is
not here, and has
not been staying with us since our sojourn in Canada.
Mr. Greeley thereupon wrote as follows:--
INTERNATIONAL HOTEL, NIAGARA
FALLS, N. Y., July 18,
1864.
GENTLEMEN:--I have the honor to acknowledge the
receipt of yours
of this date by the hand of Mr. W. C. Jewett. The state of facts
therein
presented being materially different from that which was understood
to
exist by the President when he intrusted me with the safe-conduct
required, it seems to me on every account advisable that I should
communicate with him by telegraph, and solicit fresh instructions, which
I shall
at once proceed to do.
I hope to be able to transmit the result this
afternoon, and at all events
I shall do so at the earliest moment.
Yours truly, |
HORACE GREELEY. |
To Messrs. CLEMENT C. CLAY and JAMES
P. HOLCOMBE, Clifton House,
C. W.
This letter was thus acknowledged:--
CLIFTON HOUSE, NIAGARA FALLS, July 18,
1864.
To Hon. H. GREELEY, Niagara Falls, N. Y.:
SIR:--We have the honor to acknowledge the receipt
of your note of
this date by the hands of Colonel Jewett, and will await the further
answer which you propose to send to us.
We are, very respectfully, &c.,
(Signed) |
C. C. CLAY, JR. |
|
JAMES P.
HOLCOMBE. |
Mr. Greeley accordingly sent the following telegram at once
to the President at Washington:--
INDEPENDENT TELEGRAPH LINE,
NIAGARA FALLS, July 18,
1864.
Hon. ABRAHAM
LINCOLN, President:
I have communicated with the gentlemen in question,
and do not find
them so empowered as I was previously assured. They say that "we
are, however, in the confidential employment of our Government, and
entirely familiar with its wishes and opinions on that subject, and
we feel!
authorized to declare that, if the circumstances disclosed in this
correspondence were communicated to Richmond, we would at once be
invested with
the authority to which your letter refers, or other gentlemen
clothed with
full power would immediately be sent to Washington with a view of
hastening a consummation so much to be desired, and terminating at
the
earliest possible moment the calamities of war. We respectfully
solicit,
through your intervention, a safe-conduct to Washington, and thence
by
any route which may be designated to Richmond." Such is the more
material portion of the gentlemen's letter. I will transmit the
entire
correspondence, if desired. Awaiting your further instructions,
I remain yours, |
HORACE GREELEY. |
The President, on receiving this telegram, immediately
dispatched Major Hay to Niagara with a further communication, and telegraphed to Mr. Greeley that he had
done so, whereupon the latter sent across the river the
following letter:--
INTERNATIONAL HOTEL, NIAGARA
FALLS, NEW YORK, July 19,
1864.
GENTLEMAN:--At a late hour last evening (too late
for communication
with you) I received a dispatch informing me that further
instructions
left Washington last evening, which must reach me, if there be no
interruption, at noon to-morrow. Should you decide to await their
arrival, I
feel confident that they will enable me to answer definitely your
note of
yesterday morning. Regretting a delay which I am sure you will
regard
as unavoidable on my part,
I remain
yours truly, |
HORACE GREELEY. |
To Hon. Messrs. C. C.
CLAY, JR., and J. P. HOLCOMBE, Clifton House,
C. W.
He received the following acknowledgment:--
CLIFTON HOUSE, NIAGARA FALLS, July 19,
1864.
SIR:-- Colonel Jewett has just handed us your note
of this date, in
which you state that further instructions from Washington will reach
you by noon to-morrow, if there be no interruption. One, or possibly
both of us, may be obliged to leave the Falls to-day, but will
return in
time to receive the communication which you promise to-morrow.
We remain truly yours, &c.,
JAMES P. HOLCOMBE.
C. C. CLAY, JR.
To the Hon.
HORACE GREELEY, now at the International Hotel.
The further instructions from the President, sent by the
hands of Major Hay, were as follows:--
EXECUTIVE MANSION, WASHINGTON, July 18,
1864.
TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN:
Any proposition which embraces the restoration of
peace, the integrity
of the whole Union, and the abandonment of slavery, and which comes
by and with an authority that can control the armies now at war
against
the United States, will be received and considered by the Executive
Government of the United States, and will be met by liberal terms on
substantial and collateral points, and the bearer or bearers thereof
shall
have safe conduct both ways.
(Signed) |
ABRAHAM LINCOLN. |
Major Hay arrived at Niagara on the 20th of July, and
went with Mr. Greeley across to the Clifton House, where
he delivered to Professor Holcombe the above paper, in
the President's own handwriting. The interview was a
brief one, and on separating, Mr. Greeley returned to
New York, leaving Major Hay to receive their answer,
if there should be one.
Their reply was, however, sent to Mr. Greeley by the
hands of Mr. Jewett. It was as follows:--
NIAGARA FALLS, CLIFTON HOUSE, July 21.
To Hon. HORACE GREELEY:
SIR:--The paper handed to Mr. Holcombe on
yesterday, in your presence, by Major Hay, A. A.-G., as an answer to the application in our
note
of the 18th inst., is couched in the following terms:--
EXECUTIVE MANSION, WASHINGTON, D. C., July 18,
1864.
To WHOM IT
MAY CONCERN:
Any proposition which embraces the restoration of
peace, the integrity
of the whole Union, and the abandonment of slavery, and which comes
by and with an authority that can control the armies now at war
against
the United States, will be received and considered by the Executive
Government of the United States, and will be met by liberal terms on
other substantial and collateral points, and the bearer or bearers
therof
shall have safe-conduct both ways.
ABRAHAM LINCOLN.
The application to which we refer was elicited by
your letter of the
17th inst., in which you inform Mr. Jacob Thompson and ourselves,
that
you were authorized by the President of the United States to tender
us his
safe-conduct on the hypothesis that we were "duly accredited from
Richmond, as bearers of propositions looking to the establishment of
peace," and desired a visit to Washington in the fulfilmeut of this
mission. This assertion, to which we then gave, and still do, entire
credence,
was accepted by us as the evidence of an unexpected but most
gratifying
change in the policy of the President--a change which we felt
authorized
to hope might terminate in the conclusion of a peace, mutually just,
honorable, and advantageous to the North and to the South, exacting
no condition, but that we should be "duly accredited from Richmond as
bearers
of propositions looking to the establishment of peace," thus
proffering a
basis for conference as comprehensive as we could desire. It seemed
to
us that the President opened a door, which had previously been
closed
against the Confederate States for a full interchange of sentiments,
free
discussion of conflicting opinions, and untrammelled effort to
remove all
causes of controversy by liberal negotiations. We indeed could not
claim
the benefit of a safe-conduct which had been extended to us in a
character we had no right to assume, and had never affected to possess;
but the
uniform declaration of our Executive and Congress, and their thrice
repeated and as often repulsed attempts to open negotiations, furnish
a
sufficient pledge to assure us that this conciliatory manifestation
on the
part of the President of the United States would be met by them in a
temper of equal magnanimity. We had therefore no hesitation in declaring that if this correspondence was communicated to the
President
of the Confederate States, he would promptly embrace the opportunity
presented for seeking a peaceful solution of this unhappy strife. We
feel
confident that you must share our profound regret that the spirit
which
dictated the first step towards peace had not continued to animate
the
counsels of your President.
Had the representatives of the two Governments met to
consider this
question, the most momentous ever submitted to human statesmanship,
in
a temper of becoming moderation and equity, followed as their
deliberations would have been by the prayers and benedictions of every
patriot
and Christian on the habitable globe, who is there so bold as to
pronounce
that the frightful waste of individual happiness and public
prosperity,
which is daily saddening the universal heart, might not have been
terminated, or if the desolation and carnage of war must still be endured
through weary years of blood and suffering, that there might not at
least
have been infused into its conduct something more of the spirit
which
softens and partially redeems its brutalities? Instead of the
safe-conduct
which we solicited, and which your first letter gave us every reason
to
suppose would be extended for the purpose of initiating a
negotiation in
which neither Government would compromise its rights or its dignity,
a
document has been presented which provokes as much indignation as
surprise. It bears no feature of resemblance to that which was
originally
offered, and is unlike any paper which ever before emanated from the
constitutional Executive of a free people. Addressed "to whom it may
concern," it precludes negotiation, and prescribes in advance the terms
and
conditions of peace. It returns to the original policy of "no
bargaining,
no negotiations, no truces with rebels, except to bury their dead,
until every
man shall have laid down his arms, submitted to the Government, and
sued
for mercy." What may be the explanation of this sudden and entire
change in the views of the President, of this rude withdrawal of a
courteous overture for negotiation at the moment it was likely to be
accepted, of this emphatic recall of words of peace just uttered,
and fresh blasts of
war to the bitter end, we leave for the speculation of those who
have the
means or inclination to penetrate the mysteries of his cabinet, or
fathom
the caprice of his imperial will. It is enough for us to say that we
have
no use whatever for the paper which has been placed in our hands. We
could not transmit it to the President of the Confederate States
without
offering him an indignity, dishonoring ourselves, and incurring the
well merited scorn of our countrymen.
Whilst an
ardent desire for peace pervades the people of the Confederate States, we rejoice to believe that there are few, if any, among
them,
who would purchase it at the expense of liberty, honor, and
self-respect.
If it can be secured only by their submission to terms of conquest,
the
generation is yet unborn which will witness its restitution. If
there be
any military autocrat in the North, who is entitled to proffer the
conditions of this manifesto, there is none in the South authorized to
entertain
them. Those who control our armies are the servants of the people,
not
their masters, and they have no more inclination than they have
right to
subvert the social institutions of the sovereign States, to
overthrow their
established constitutions, and to barter away their priceless
heritage of
self-government.
This correspondence will not, however, we trust,
prove wholly barren
of good results.
If there is any citizen of the Confederate States
who has clung to a
hope that peace was possible with this Administration of the Federal
Government, it will strip from his eyes the last film of such a
delusion; or if
there be any whose hearts have grown faint under the suffering and
agony
of this bloody struggle, it will inspire them with fresh energy to
endure
and brave whatever may yet be requisite to preserve to themselves
and
their children all that gives dignity and value to life, or hope and
consolation to death. And if there be any patriots or Christians in your
land,
who shrink appalled from the illimitable vista of private misery and
public calamity which stretches before them, we pray that in their
bosoms
a resolution may be quickened to recall the abused authority and vindicate the outraged civilization of their country. For the
solicitude you
have manifested to inaugurate a movement which contemplates results
the
most noble and humane, we return our sincere thanks, and are most
respectfully and truly
Your obedient servants,
C. C. CLAY, JR.
JAMES P. HOLCOMBE.
The letter to Mr. Jewett in which it was enclosed was as
follows:--
CLIFTON HOUSE, NIAGARA FALLS, July 20,
1864.
Col. W. C.
JEWETT, Cataract House, Niagara Falls:
We are in receipt of your note admonishing us of
the departure of Hon.
Horace Greeley from the Falls, that he regrets the sad termination
of the
initiatory
steps taken for peace, in consequence of the change made by
the President in his instructions to convey commissioners to
Washington
for negotiations, unconditionally, and that Mr. Greeley will be
pleased to
receive any answer we may have to make through you. We avail our selves of this offer to enclose a letter to Mr. Greeley, which you
will oblige
us by delivering. We cannot take leave of you without expressing our
thanks for your courtesy and kind offices as the intermediary
through
whom our correspondence with Mr. Greeley has been conducted, and assuring you that we are, very respectfully,
Your obedient servants,
C. C. CLAY, JR.
JAMES P. HOLCOMBE.
Mr. Greeley, before his departure, gave the following certificate
to Mr. Jewett:--
INTERNATIONAL HOTEL, NIAGARA
FALLS, July 20,
1864.
In leaving
the Falls, I feel bound to state that I have had no intercourse
with the Confederate gentlemen at the Clifton House, but such as I
was
fully authorized to hold by the President of the United States, and
that I
have done nothing in the premises but in fulfilment of his
injunctions.
The notes, therefore, which you have interchanged between those
gentle men and myself, can in no case subject you to the imputation of
unauthorized dealing with public enemies
HORACE GREELEY.
To W. C. JEWETT, Esq.
In their note of July 20, to Mr. Jewett, enclosing their
final letter to Mr. Greeley, the rebel emissaries acknowledge the assurance, received from Mr. Jewett, that Mr.
Greeley "regrets the sad termination of the initiatory
steps taken for peace, in consequence of the change made
by the President in his instructions to convey commissioners to Washington for negotiations unconditionally."
The Commissioners must have misunderstood Mr. Jewett,
or Mr. Jewett must have misrepresented. Mr. Greeley, in
this report of the ground of his "regrets," or else Mr.
Greeley must have taken a position quite at variance with
the facts of the case. Mr. Greeley could scarcely have
believed that the President had "changed his instructions" in the least degree; and he must have known that
the result of the attempted negotiation was due to a wholly
different cause.
The first response made by the President to Mr. Greeley's urgent
entreaty that peace commissioners should be received, was dated July 9, and said:--
"If you can
find any person professing to have any proposition of
Jefferson Davis, in writing, for peace, embracing
the restoration of the
Union, and abandonment of slavery, whatever else it embraces,
say to
him that he may come to me."
At the very outset, therefore, the President distinctly
specified the conditions on which he would receive the
pretended commissioners:--they must bring written propositions for peace from Davis, and those propositions
must embrace two of the things which Mr. Greeley himself
had suggested,--the restoration of the Union, and the abandonment of slavery. So far as appears, Mr. Greeley
neither showed this letter of the President to the pretended
agents of the Rebel Government, nor did he inform them
in any way of the conditions on which alone they would
be received. But in his letters of July 10th and 13th, to
the President, without making any reference to these conditions, he reiterates his pressing entreaty that the negotiations may be encouraged, and that the rebel agents may
be received at Washington. To this the President replied,
expressing his disappointment that the commissioners had
not already arrived, and saying,
"If they
would consent to come, on being shown my letter to you of
the 9th inst. [in which the conditions of their coming were
distinctly
stated], show that and
this to them, and if they will come on the terms
stated in the former, bring them."
Notwithstanding these explicit and peremptory instructions, it does not appear that Mr. Greeley gave the rebel
agents any information whatever as to the "terms" of
their being received, nor did he show them either of
the President's two letters in which these terms were
stated. But he proceeded to make arrangements for their
visit to Washington, and went to Niagara Falls to bear
them company. There he addressed them a letter on the
17th of July, saying that, if it was true, as he had been informed, that they were "duly accredited from Richmond as
the bearers of propositions looking to the establishment
of peace, and in the fulfilment of their mission," he was "authorized by
the President of the United States to tender
them his safe-conduct on the journey proposed." Mr. Greeley was not authorized to tender these agents a safe-conduct
to Washington upon any such terms, but only on certain
other conditions which he concealed from the agents, and
of which he took no notice whatever, either in his correspondence with them or with the President. Their reply
to him, however, corrected his impression that they were
"duly accredited" from Richmond to negotiate for peace.
They had no authority of the kind, but expressed their
belief that they could get it, and, upon this presumption,
renewed their solicitations for a safe-conduct to Washington. On the 18th, Mr. Greeley wrote to the President
communicating this information, but still making no allusion whatever to the conditions imposed upon their being
received.
The President, meantime, not understanding the cause
of delay in their arrival, sent Major Hay, his private secretary, to communicate directly with "any persons" professing to have authority from Davis to treat for peace,
and to inform them, as he had twice before instructed
Mr. Greeley to inform them, that any proposition for
peace, in order to be received and considered by him,
must embrace "the restoration of peace, the integrity of
the whole Union, and the abandonment of slavery."
These instructions were embodied in the letter addressed
"to whom it may concern"--and were delivered by
Major Hay in person to the rebel agents. As it was the
first they had ever heard of any "conditions," and as
they had been informed by Mr. Greeley that he was instructed by the President to tender them safe-conduct to
Washington, without any mention of conditions--they
were of course taken by surprise, and naturally enough
attributed to the President the "sudden and entire
change of views" with which they reproach him in their
letter to Mr. Greeley of July 21st. And strangely enough,
even after receiving this letter and being thus apprised
of the charge brought against the President, Mr. Greeley
not only failed to relieve him from it by making public the facts, but
joined in ascribing to Mr. Lincoln the failure of negotiations for peace and the consequent prolongation of the war. And, according to Mr. Jewett's statement, Mr. Greeley also authorized him to express to the
rebel commissioners his regrets, that the negotiation
should have failed in consequence of the President's
change of views."
It is not easy now, any more than it was then, to
reconcile Mr. Greeley's action in this matter with fidelity
to the Union cause, or with good faith to the Administration, by which alone that cause was maintained. The
Opposition press made Mr. Lincoln's alleged tergiversation the ground of fresh and vehement attack, while it
was used throughout the rebel States as fresh proof of
the faithless character of the Federal Government, and
of the absolute impossibility of making peace except by
successful war. The commissioners themselves made a
very adroit use of the advantage which Mr. Greeley's
extraordinary course had placed in their hands, and, in
their letter of July 21st, addressed to him, but intended
to be a public impeachment of President Lincoln's honor
and good faith, made a powerful and effective appeal to
the indignant pride of the Southern people and the sympathy of their friends in the Northern States.
The President felt very sensibly the injustice done to
himself, and the' injury done the country, by Mr. Greeley's
suppression of these most essential facts, in his intercourse
with the rebel commissioners. As the only mode of
placing the whole subject properly before the people,
he applied to Mr. Greeley for permission to publish the
whole correspondence -- omitting only certain passages
not at all essential to a full understanding of the subject,
and likely seriously to injure the Union cause by infusing
into the public mind something of the despondency,
which Mr. Greeley himself felt and openly avowed, concerning the prospects of the country. The words which
Mr. Lincoln desired to have omitted, in the publication
of the correspondence, were the following. In the letter
of July 7:--
In the second
paragraph: the words "and therefore I venture to re mind you that our bleeding, bankrupt, almost dying country also
longs
for peace, shudders at the prospect of fresh conscriptions, of
further
wholesale devastations, and of new rivers of human blood,
and:"--also
the words "now, and is morally certain, unless removed, to do far
greater in the approaching elections."
In the fourth paragraph, the words "If only with a
view to the momentous election soon to occur in North Carolina and of the draft to
be
enforced in the Free States, this should be done."
In the last paragraph, the words "It may save us
from a Northern insurrection.
In the letter of July 10th, second paragraph, the
words "in season
for effect on the approaching North Carolina election;" and in the
last
paragraph, the words "especially those of North Carolina."
And in the letter of July 13th, last paragraph, the
words "that a good
influence may even yet be exerted on the North Carolina election
next
month."
Mr. Greeley declined to give his assent to the publication of the correspondence, unless these phrases should be
published also. The President accordingly submitted in
silence to the injustice which had been done him, and committed the whole subject, in the following letter, to the judgment of a personal and political friend:--
EXECUTIVE MANSION, WASHINGTON August 15,
1864.
Hon. HENRY J. RAYMOND:
My DEAR SIR:--I have proposed to Mr. Greeley that
the Niagara correspondence be published, suppressing only the parts of his letters
over
which the red-pencil is drawn in the copy which I herewith send. He
declines giving his consent to the publication of his letters unless
these
parts be published with the rest. I have concluded that it is better
for
me to submit, for the time, to the consequences of the false
position in
which I consider he has placed me, than to subject the country to
the
consequences of publishing these discouraging and injurious parts. I
send you this, and the accompanying copy, not for publication, but
merely
to explain to you, and that you may preserve them until their proper
time shall come.
Yours truly,
ABRAHAM LINCOLN.
FAC-SIMILE OF PRESIDENT LINCOLN'S LETTER TO MR. RAYMOND
This public statement of the facts of this case is deemed
by the author due to the memory of Mr. Lincoln. He
has been widely censured for entering into communication with rebel agents at all;--but this correspondence
shows that Mr. Greeley's assurances, and his pressing entreaties, had made it necessary for him, either to open the way for
peace negotiations or reject the opportunity, which one.
of the most influential leaders of his own party thus assured
him was offered, for an honorable termination of the war.
He was charged with having finally insisted upon certain
concessions as the basis of an interview, after having first
promised it unconditionally; but this correspondence
shows that these conditions were distinctly stated at the
very outset, but were withheld by Mr. Greeley from the
knowledge of the rebel commissioners. It is due to justice, as well as to Mr. Lincoln, that impressions so injurious
and so false should no longer prevail.
The effect of this attempt at negotiation upon the public
mind was, for the moment, unfavorable to the Union cause.
The people, responding heartily to the demand of the Baltimore Platform, that no peace should be accepted by the
Government on any terms short of an unconditional surrender, were distrustful of negotiations which might look
to some other issue. The charge of bad faith urged
against the President stimulated the Opposition, and, in
the absence of the facts, embarrassed his supporters; while
the fact that Mr. Lincoln insisted upon the abandonment
of slavery as one of the conditions of peace, was cited by
the opponents of his Administration as proof that the
object of the war was changed, and that it was to be waged
hereafter, not solely for the preservation of the Union, but
for the emancipation of the slaves. In the absence of any
opposing candidate, these and countless other charges were
urged against the Administration with marked effect, and
added very materially to the popular despondency which
the lack of military success had naturally engendered.
Eager to avail themselves to the utmost of this auspicious
condition of political affairs, and embarrassed not a little
by discordant sentiments in their own ranks, the Democratic party had postponed their National Convention for
the nomination of a President from the 22d of June to the
29th of August. But the delay from which they expected
so much, in fact, betrayed them into a confidence which
proved fatal to their hopes. Their expectations, however,
were not without reason. The state of the public mind was favorable to
the success of their plans. The assaults upon the Administration had grown more virulent, and seemed to produce more effect. Many of its
friends, who, when Mr. Lincoln was renominated, had
considered the main work of the political campaign over,
had grown gradually doubtful. The uncertainty as to
the course which the Democratic party would pursue
compelled them almost to inaction, at least so far as offensive warfare was concerned, while they were themselves
exposed to every kind of attack. And when the time for
the Chicago Convention came, its managers gathered to it
with high hopes, believing that if they could only unite
upon a candidate and a platform which should not violently offend either wing of the party, their success was
certain. The peace wing of the party, however, had been
relatively strengthened in the interim. The delays and
losses of the armies, the hope deferred to which the long
and bloody struggles in Virginia and in Georgia had familiarized but not inured the popular heart, the rise in
gold, the call for five hundred thousand more men--all
these things had given them strength, and made them more
vehement and more exacting. Their great champion, Mr.
Vallandigham, had surreptitiously returned from Canada,
in violation of the sentence which ordered his banishment
from the lines during the war, and had remained in open
defiance of the Government, whose failure to arrest and
send him back, or otherwise to punish him, was treated
then as an indication of weakness rather than of wisdom.
He and his friends were active everywhere, and did not
hesitate to declare that they must have a peace candidate, or platform, one or both, at all hazards, and
threatened to nominate a candidate of their own, if this
course was not pursued. It cannot be doubted that the
fatal course which was finally adopted by the Convention
was largely due to the efforts of Mr. Vallandigham, and
to the encouragement which his friends received from the
apparent unwillingness of the Government to molest him
on his return.
The Convention met in Chicago on Monday, August 29.
It was called to order by August Belmont, of New York,
the Chairman of the National Committee, on whose motion
Ex-Governor Bigler, of Pennsylvania, was appointed
temporary Chairman. The business transacted on the
first day embraced the appointment of Committees on
Credentials, Organization, and Resolutions, of which latter
committee Mr. Vallandigham was chosen chairman.
On Tuesday the committees reported. There were no
contested delegations except from Kentucky, and this
question the committee settled by admitting both delegations and dividing the vote between them. Louisiana
and the Territories had sent delegates, but these were at
once excluded. Governor Horatio Seymour, of New York,
was chosen President of the Convention, with twenty-one
vice-presidents and secretaries. In the afternoon, the
platform was reported.
The second resolution, which embodied the spirit of
the Convention, and shaped the succeeding canvass, was
as follows:--
Resolved,
That this Convention does explicitly declare, as the sense of
the American people, that after four years of failure to restore the
Union
by the experiment of war, during which, under the pretence. of
military
necessity or war power higher than the Constitution, the
Constitution
itself has been disregarded in every part, and public liberty and
private
right alike trodden down, and the material prosperity of the country
essentially impaired, justice, humanity, liberty, and the public
welfare
demand that immediate efforts be made for a cessation of
hostilities, with
a view to an ultimate convention of the States or other peaceable
means,
to the end that, at the earliest practicable moment, peace may be
restored
on the basis of the Federal Union of the States.
The other resolutions assailed the Administration for
its military interference in elections, its arbitrary arrests,
suppression of freedom of speech and of the press, denial
of the right of asylum, imposing test-oaths, taking away
arms from the people (as had been done where there was
danger of armed insurrection on the part of local associations), and disregard of duty towards our soldiers who
were prisoners of war; and they extended "the sympathy of the Democratic party" to the soldiers and the
sailors.
Mr. Long, of Ohio, who, as will be recollected, had been
publicly censured by Congress for a speech bordering
upon treason, endeavored to amend the resolutions so as
to "place the Convention in a position favoring peace
beyond the mistakes of any equivocal language." Under
the working of the previous question, however, Mr. Long
was silenced, and the resolutions were adopted with but
four dissenting votes.
The Convention then proceeded to the nomination of
a candidate for President. The nomination of General
McClellan was the signal for a fierce attack upon him by
some of the ultra peace men, but he was vigorously
defended, and the debate lasted till darkness compelled
an adjournment. The vote was taken, as soon as the
Convention met in the morning, and General McClellan
received one hundred and sixty-two votes out of two
hundred and twenty-eight, and this number was increased
to two hundred and two and a half before the ballot
was announced; the rest having been cast for Thomas
H. Seymour, of Connecticut.
For Vice-President, the Convention nominated George
H. Pendleton, of Ohio, whose position was unqualifiedly
among the ultra peace men.
Mr. Wickliffe, of Kentucky, saying that "the delegates
from the West were of the opinion that circumstances
may occur between noon of to-day and the fourth of
March next, which will make it proper for the Democracy
of the country to meet in convention again," moved the
following resolution:--
Resolved,
That this Convention shall not be dissolved by adjournment
at the close of its business, but shall remain organized, subject to
be called
at any time and place that the Executive National Committee shall
designate.
This suggestive resolution was unanimously adopted,
and the Convention then separated.
The action of the Convention was eminently cheering
to the friends of the Administration. It was more open
and honest than they had anticipated; it avowed sentiments which, though entertained, it was feared would be concealed. The
whole tone of the Convention had
been in opposition to the popular feeling on the war.
The ultra peace men had been prominent in its deliberations. Vallandigham, Harris, Long, Pendleton, men who
had done their utmost to help on the rebellion and
hamper the Government, had been its ruling spirits.
The tone of its speeches had been in entire sympathy
with the rebels, for whom no words of reproof were
uttered, while they were unmeasured in their denunciation of Mr. Lincoln and his Administration. The
news of the fall of Fort Morgan had come in upon them
as they sat in conclave, but it won no cheers from that
assembly for the success of the Old Flag and the leaf
of imperishable renown which added to the full wreath
of laurel, which already crowned our army and our
navy. Its resolutions had declared that the war was
a failure, and called for an immediate cessation of hostilities; while, as a striking commentary upon this declaration, the very day after the Convention adjourned
brought the news of the fall of Atlanta and the glorious
success of that grand march of Sherman's army which
turned the tide of war, and contributed so largely to its
final success.
The Union party instantly and joyfully accepted the
issue thus boldly tendered. They knew that, once fairly
before the country, the result could not be doubtful.
The people did not believe that the effort to maintain
the Union by force of arms had yet proved "a failure."
They did not believe that the Union could be preserved
by negotiation, and they were not in favor of a cessation
of hostilities until victory should be secured. The issue
had been fairly made between the two parties in their
respective declarations at Baltimore and Chicago. The
former demanded a vigorous prosecution of the war, and
denounced all terms of peace short of an unconditional
surrender of the rebels; the latter demanded a suspension
of hostilities and a resort to negotiation.
The great body of the Democratic party throughout the
country, sympathizing with the national sentiment, felt that they had
been placed in a false position by the action
of their convention. An effort was made to stem the
rising tide of public condemnation by General McClellan,
their candidate for the Presidency, in his letter of acceptance. He declared himself in favor of preserving the
Union by a vigorous prosecution of the war, if all the
"resources of statesmanship," which should be first employed, should prove inadequate. The letter, however,
was without effect. It did something to alienate the peace
men who had controlled the Chicago Convention, but
nothing to disturb the conviction of the people that the
same men would control General McClellan also in the
event of his election.
The political campaign was thus fairly opened. The
Fremont movement, which had but little strength from
the start, now came to an inglorious end. Shortly before
the meeting of the Chicago Convention, some friends of
General Fremont, with some faint hope of compelling Mr.
Lincoln to withdraw, had written to the General to know
if he would withdraw from the canvass, provided Mr.
Lincoln would do so. In reply, General Fremont, saying
that he had no right to act independently of the men
who nominated him, suggested that some understanding
should be had between the supporters of the Baltimore
and Cleveland Conventions, with a view to the convocation of a third convention; for, as he said, "a really popular convention, upon a broad and liberal basis, so that
it could be regarded as a convocation in mass of the
people, and not the work of politicians, would command
public confidence." The proposition, however, commanded not the slightest attention; and after the Democratic nomination was made, the lines were drawn so
closely that the pressure of public sentiment compelled
the absolute withdrawal of General Fremont, which took
place on the 21st of September. From that time forward
the contest was between Mr. Lincoln, representing the
sentiments of the Baltimore Platform on the one hand,
and General McClellan, representing the sentiments of the
Chicago Platform on the other. The lines were clearly drawn, and the
canvass was prosecuted with earnestness,
but with less than the usual acrimony and intemperate
zeal. It was felt to be a contest of principle, and was
carried on with a gravity and decorum befitting its importance.
One of the incidents upon which great stress was laid
by the Opposition in the canvass, arose out of some proceedings in Tennessee, of which Andrew Johnson still
remained military governor, with reference to the calling
of a convention and holding an election in the State.
Several efforts had been made in that direction during the
year. As early as January 26th, Governor Johnson had
issued a proclamation, ordering an election for county
officers, and in his proclamation had prescribed stringent
qualifications for voters, and a stringent oath which every
voter must take. Some of the judges of election thought,
however, that it was enough to require of voters to take
the oath of the President's amnesty proclamation. Accordingly, one of them wrote to Washington on the subject, as follows:--
NASHVILLE, February 20,
1864.
Hon. W. H. SEWARD, Secretary of State, Washington,
D. C.:
In county and State elections, must citizens of
Tennessee take the oath
prescribed by Governor Johnson, or will the President's oath of
amnesty
entitle them to vote? I have been appointed to hold the March
election
in Cheatham County, and wish to act understandingly.
WARREN JORDAN.
The President himself answered by telegraph as follows:--
WASHINGTON, February 20,
1864.
WARREN JORDAN, Nashville:
In county elections you had better stand by
Governor Johnson's plan;
otherwise you will have conflict and confusion. I have seen his
plan.
A. LINCOLN.
This election was held with but indifferent success. A
convention was also held in May at Knoxville, but took
no important action. But, in September, another convention was called together for the purpose of reorganizing the State
and taking part in the approaching Presidential election. The convention met, and determined
that the election should be held. They adopted an electoral ticket, and provided for ascertaining the qualifications of voters. Among other things, they provided a
stringent oath, to be administered to registers and officers
holding the elections, and requested Governor Johnson
to execute the resolutions which they had adopted "in
such manner as he might think would best subserve the
interests of the Government."
Governor Johnson accordingly, on the 30th of September, issued a proclamation, directing that the election be
opened and held, and that at such election "all citizens
and soldiers, being free white men, twenty-one years of
age, citizens of the United States, and for six months
prior to the election citizens of the State of Tennessee,
who have qualified themselves by registration, and who
take the oath prescribed" by the convention, should be.
entitled to vote. The oath prescribed was as follows:--
"I solemnly
swear that I will henceforth support the Constitution of
the United States, and defend it against the assaults of all
enemies: that
I am an active friend of the Government of the United States, and
the
enemy of the so-called Confederate States: that I ardently desire
the suppression of the present rebellion against the Government of the
United
States: that I sincerely rejoice in the triumph of the armies and
navies
of the United States, and in the defeat and overthrow of the armies,
navies, and of all armed combinations in the interest of the
so-called Con federate States: that I will cordially oppose all armistices and
negotiations for peace with rebels in arms, until the Constitution of the
United
States, and all laws and proclamations made in pursuance thereof,
shall
be established over all the people of every State and Territory
embraced
within the National Union; and that I will heartily aid and assist
the
loyal people in whatever measures may be adopted for the attainment
of
these ends: and further, that I take this oath freely and
voluntarily, and
without mental reservation. So help me God."
An electoral ticket in favor of General McClellan had
previously been nominated by persons not in sympathy
with the State Convention, nor with the National Administration, and these gentlemen, on the appearance of
this proclamation, drew up a protest, which they addressed to the
President. They protested against Governor Johnson's assuming to dictate the qualifications of voters,
which they said were prescribed by the laws of Tennessee,
a copy of which they annexed; and they protested against
the oath.
This protest was presented to the President by Mr. J.
Lellyet one of the signers, who sent to a New York newspaper the following account of the interview.
WASHINGTON, October 15.
I called upon the President to-day, and presented
and read to him the
subjoined protest. Having concluded, Mr. Lincoln responded:--
"May I inquire how long it took you and the New
York politicians to
concoct that paper?"
I replied, "It was concocted in Nashville, without
communication with
any but Tennesseans. We communicated with citizens of Tennessee out side of Nashville, but not with New York politicians."
"I will answer," said Mr. Lincoln, emphatically,
"that I expect to let
the friends of George B. McClellan manage their side of this contest
in
their own way, and I will manage my side of it in my way."
"May we ask an answer in writing?" I suggested.
"Not now. Lay those papers down here. I will give
no other answer
now. I may or I may not write something about this hereafter. I understand this. I know you intend to make a point of this. But go
ahead, you have my answer."
"Your answer then is that you expect to let General
McClellan's friends
manage their side of the contest in their own way, and you will
manage
your side of it in your way?"
"Yes."
I then thanked the President for his courtesy in
giving us a hearing at
and then took my leave. * * *
JOHN LELLYET.
The President, a few days after, however, sent them
the following answer in writing:
EXECUTIVE MANSION, WASHINGTON,
D. C., October 22,
1864.
Messrs. WILLIAM B. CAMPBELL, THOMAS A. R. NELSON,
JAMES T. P.
CARTER, JOHN WILLIAMS, A. BLIZZARD, HENRY COOPER, BAILLIE
PEYTON, JOHN LELLYET, EMERSON ETHERIDGE, and JOHN D. PERRY
MAN:
Gentlemen:--On the 15th day of this month,
as I remember, a printed
paper manuscript, with a few manuscript interlineations, called a
protest,
with your names appended thereto, and accompanied by another printed
paper, purporting to be a proclamation by Andrew Johnson, Military
Governor of Tennessee, and also a manuscript paper, purporting to be
extracts from the Code of Tennessee, were laid before me.
The protest, proclamation, and extracts are
respectively as follows:--
[The
protest is here recited, and also the proclamation of Governor
Johnson, dated September 30, to which it refers, together with a
list of
the counties in East, Middle, and West Tennessee; also extracts
from the
Code of Tennessee in relation to electors of President and
Vice-President,
qualifications of voters for members of the General Assembly,
places
of holding elections, and officers of popular elections.]
At the time these papers were presented, as before
stated, I had never
seen either of them, nor heard of the subject to which they relate,
except
in a general way one day previously.
Up to the present moment, nothing whatever upon the
subject has
passed between Governor Johnson, or any one else, connected with the
proclamation, and myself.
Since receiving the papers, as stated, I have given
the subject such
brief consideration as I have been able to do, in the midst of so
many
pressing public duties.
My conclusion is, that I can have nothing to do with
the matter, either
to sustain the plan as the convention and Governor Johnson have
initiated
it, or to revoke or modify it as you demand.
By the Constitution and laws, the President is
charged with no duty in
the Presidential election in any State, nor do I in this case
perceive any
military reason for his interference in the matter.
The movement set on foot by the convention and
Governor Johnson
does not, as seems to be assumed by you, emanate from the National
Executive.
In no proper sense can it be considered other than an
independent
movement of, at least, a portion of the loyal people of Tennessee.
I do not perceive in the plan any menace, or
violence, or coercion towards
any one.
Governor Johnson, like any other loyal citizen of
Tennessee, has the
right to favor any political plan he chooses, and, as military
governor, it
is his duty to keep the peace among and for the loyal people of the
State.
I cannot discern that by this plan he purposes any
more. But you object to the plan.
Leaving it alone will be your perfect security
against it. It is not pro posed to force you into it.
Do as you please, on your own account, peaceably and
loyally, and Governor Johnson will not molest you, but will protect you against
violence
as far as in his power.
I presume that the conducting of a Presidential
election in Tennessee in
strict accordance with the old code of the State, is not now a
possibility.
It is scarcely necessary to add, that if any election
shall be held and
any votes shall be east in the State of Tennessee for President and
Vice-President of the United States, it will not belong to the
military agents,
nor yet to the Executive Department, but exclusively to another
department of the Government, to determine whether they are entitled to be
counted in conformity with the Constitution and laws of the United
States.
Except it be
to give protection against violence, I decline to interfere in
any way with any Presidential election.
ABRAHAM LINCOLN.
The signers of the protest thereupon declared the McClellan electoral ticket withdrawn. And this incident
was made the basis of fresh attacks upon the President
for interfering in the election.
Like all other persons in similar position, Mr. Lincoln
was subjected to assaults upon his personal character and
conduct. One of these charges was, that while all other
public creditors drew their compensation in paper money,
his salary was paid in gold. The charge is important,
now, only because it led to the publication of the following letter from the Treasurer of the United States:--
UNITED STATES TREASURY,
WASHINGTON, October 13.
MY DEAR
SIR:--Since the receipt of your letter of the 10th instant, I
have found the article spoken of by you, and which, although I am
told it
has gone the rounds of the Democratic press, I have not before seen.
It
is in the words following:--
" Jeff. Davis's salary is nominally twenty-five
thousand a year, but by
the depreciation of the Confederate money is equal to about fifteen
hundred
dollars, and on this practically he has to live. Abraham Lincoln's
salary
is legally twenty-five thousand dollars a year. But his legal-tender
money,
having depreciated to less than half its nominal value, he refuses
to take,
and demands and receives his pay in gold or gold certificates, while
the
soldiers of his army have to take their pay in greenbacks. Isn't
this pa triotic and honest in Old Abe, and ought not he to be re-elected to
another
four years' hard money for himself, and of largely depreciated money
for
the people?"
Now, this story is perhaps as true as other
slanders that have been
heaped upon the head of Mr. Lincoln by his malignant Copperhead and
traitor enemies, North and South. The facts in the case, however,
are
entirely at variance with, and the very reverse of, the statements
made in
the article quoted. The salary of the President is, in accordance
with law,
paid in warrant drafts on the Treasury of the United States for the
amount,
less the income tax, which have been sent him regularly monthly.
Instead
of drawing his money on these drafts, he has been in the habit of
leaving it for a long time without interest. In one case all his
salary so remained
for eleven months. On several occasions I solicited the President to
draw
what was due him, urging that he was losing largely in interest on
the
amount due him. He asked me, "Who gains my loss?" On my answering, "The United States," he replied, "Then as it goes for the
good
of the country, let it remain. The Treasury needs it more than I
do."
Having at length satisfied the President that it was necessary to
the closing of my annual accounts that the drafts on the Treasury that he
held
should be presented and paid, he indorsed and handed them to me. I
drew
the amount in United States notes, and placed it to his credit as a
temporary
loan at five per cent. per annum, payable, principal and interest,
in green backs. Since then his salary has been from time to time mostly
invested in
the stocks of the United States, purchased at current rates by his
friends
for him. The interest of these stocks is payable in coin. When this
interest became due, I tried to induce him to draw it. Failing in
doing so,
the amount due him was sent by Honorable John O. Underwood, Judge
of the United States Court for the District of Virginia. The result
of his
interview with the President is best told in the letter of Judge
Underwood
to me, which is herewith enclosed to you. I have caused an
investigation
to be made of the transactions of the President with the receipt of
his
salary, and the investment of the sums in United States stocks, and
enclose
you herewith the letter of Leroy Tuttle, Esq., the Assistant
Cashier, from
which it appears that Mr. Lincoln, from his forbearance in
collecting his
dues, has lost at least four thousand dollars, and which he has
virtually
given to the people of the United States. I have great doubts as to
the propriety of answering this foul falsehood, well knowing that others
perhaps
even grosser will be made, so as to keep the Union party on the
defensive,
and thus preventing the loyal men of the country from attacking the
peace at-any-price Democracy for their damning heresies and treasonable
practices. You, however, ask me to make the statement and to put it in
an
official form. I have therefore done so, and I authorize you to use
it
and the accompanying letters, or any part of either, in any way that
may seem best calculated to place the President and his calumniators
in
their true light and positions before the American people.
Very respectfully yours,
F. E. SPINNER, U.
S. Treasurer.
To General D.
W. O. CLARKE, Burlington, Vermont.
We may say here, that this gift of money to the cause
of the country was not the only way in which Mr. Lincoln shared in the burdens of the war. He set an example to his fellow-citizens, also, by sending a representative recruit to the army.
The differences in the Union ranks had all disappeared
before the common danger. Efforts were made on every
side, not for discord, but for harmony and united effort.
With this desire, and in accordance with an intimation
in the Baltimore Platform that a change in the Cabinet
would be desirable, Mr. Lincoln determined to displace
Mr. Blair from the position of Postmaster-General. The
following correspondence passed between them:--
EXECUTIVE MANSION, WASHINGTON, September 23,
1864.
Hen. MONTGOMERY BLAIR:
MY DEAR SIR:--You have generously said to me, more
than once, that
whenever your resignation could be a relief to me, it was at my
disposal.
The time has come. You very well know that this proceeds from no dissatisfaction of mine with you personally or officially. Your uniform
kindness has been unsurpassed by that of any other friend, and while
it is
true that the war does not so greatly add to the difficulties of
your department as to those of some others, it is yet much to say, as I
most truly
can, that in the three years and a half during which you have
administered the General Post-Office, I remember no single complaint
against you
in connection therewith.
Yours, as ever,
A. LINCOLN.
MR. BLAIR'S REPLY.
MY DEAR SIR:--I have received your
note of this date, referring to my
offers to resign whenever you should deem it advisable for the
public interest that I should do so, and stating that, in your judgment, that
time
has now come. I now, therefore, formally tender my resignation of
the
office of Postmaster-General. I cannot take leave of you without
renew ing the expressions of my gratitude for the uniform kindness which
has
marked your course towards
Yours truly,
M. BLAIR.
THE
PRESIDENT.
The political canvass was prosecuted with energy and
confidence in every section of the country. The main consideration which was pressed upon the public mind was,
that the defeat of Mr. Lincoln would be, in the eyes of
the rebels, an explicit disapproval of the general line of
policy he had pursued, and a distinct repudiation by the
people of the Northern States of the Baltimore declaration, that the war should be prosecuted to the complete
and final overthrow of the rebellion. This view of the
case completely controlled the sentiment and action of
the people, and left little room or disposition for wrangling over the
many petty issues to which such a contest
gives birth. As the canvass advanced the confidence of
success increased, and received a still further impulse
from the grand military victories which, in quick succession, began to crown the Union arms.
During the months of September and October, General
Hood, in a vain endeavor to regain the ground lost by the
fall of Atlanta, made a movement upon General Sherman's
communications. He might have caused some trouble, if
it had not been for the gallant defence of Alatoona, by
General Corse, which enabled Sherman to adopt such
measures as drove Hood away from his line of communication, into the northern part of Alabama, where he gathered
his forces for that fatal march which led his army to be
crushed upon the heights of Nashville.
General Grant had not been idle before Petersburg during this time. Several attacks had been made by our
forces both on the north side of the James and towards
the south of Petersburg, resulting in steady gains for
Grant's operations.
But the most important of all were the brilliant victories
gained by General Sheridan, in the Shenandoah Valley,
one on September 19th, near Winchester, the second three
days later, at Fisher's Hill, and the greatest of all at Cedar
Creek, on the 19th of October, when what had already
been a repulse of our army, by a surprise on the part of
General Early, was turned into a glorious victory by the
timely arrival of Sheridan, who on his return from
Washington, hearing the guns of the battle at Winchester, rode full speed to join his men, whom he reformed
and led instantly to the destruction of the exalting
rebels.
It was with the joy of this last victory kindling his
heart, that the President, on the 20th of October, issued
his proclamation for a national thanksgiving, as follows:--
A PROCLAMATION.
It has
pleased Almighty God to prolong our national life another year,
defending us with His guardian care against unfriendly, designs,
from
abroad, and vouchsafing to us in His mercy many and signal victories
over the enemy who is of our own household. It has also pleased our
Heavenly
Father to favor as well our citizens in their homes as our soldiers
in their
camps and our sailors on the rivers and seas, with unusual health.
He
has largely augmented our free population by emancipation and by
immigration, while He has opened to us new sources of wealth, and has
crowned the labor of our workingmen in every department of industry
with abundant reward. Moreover, He has been pleased to animate and
inspire our minds and hearts with fortitude, courage, and resolution
sufficient for the great trial of civil war, into which we have been
brought by
our adherence as a nation to the cause of freedom and humanity, and
to
afford to us reasonable hopes of an ultimate and happy deliverance
from
all our dangers and affliction.
Now, therefore, I, Abraham Lincoln, President of
the United States, do
hereby appoint and set apart the last Thursday in November next, as
a
day which I desire to be observed by all my fellow-citizens,
wherever they
may then be, as a day of thanksgiving and prayer to Almighty God,
the
beneficent Creator and Ruler of the universe; and I do further
recommend
to my fellow-citizens aforesaid, that on that occasion they do
reverently
humble themselves in the dust, and from thence offer up penitent and
fer vent prayers and supplications to the great Disposer of events, for
a return
of the inestimable blessings of peace, union, and harmony throughout
the
land, which it has pleased Him to assign as a dwelling-place for
ourselves
and our posterity, throughout all generations.
In testimony whereof, I have hereunto set my hand
and caused the seal
of the United States to be affixed.
Done at the City of Washington, this
twentieth day of October, in
the year of Lord one thousand eight hundred and sixty-four, and
of the independence of the United States the eighty-ninth. |
[L. S.] |
ABRAHAM LINCOLN.
By the President:
WILLIAM H. SEWARD, Secretary
of State.
He also wrote the following letter of congratulation to
General Sheridan, which was read at the head of every
regiment in the command:--
EXECUTIVE MANSION, WASHINGTON, October 22.
To
Major-General SHERIDAN:
With great pleasure I tender to you, and your brave
army, the thanks
of the nation and my own personal admiration and gratitude for the
month's operations in the Shenandoah Valley, and especially for the
splendid work of October 19.
Your obedient servant,
ABRAHAM LINCOLN.
These victories gave vigor and courage to the country.
The price of gold fell in the market, the credit of the Government was
rapidly enhanced, volunteers swelled
the ranks of the army, and the menaced draft promised
to be unnecessary.
The term for Which the hundred-days men from the
West had enlisted had expired, and the men were sent
home, having done good service. Those from Ohio had
served in the east, while those from the States farther west
had aided Sherman's march; when they were discharged
the following complimentary orders, by President Lincoln,
Were issued:--
THANKS TO THE OHIO
TROOPS.
WASHINGTON, September 10.
Governor BROUGH:
Pursuant to the President's directions, I transmit
to you the following
Executive order, made by him in acknowledgment of the services of
the
hundred-day men, who at the opening of the spring campaign
volunteered
their service in the operations of General Grant. The certificates
of ser vices mentioned in the order will be prepared without delay and
trans mitted to the officers and soldiers entitled to them.
EDWIN M. STANTON, Secretary
of War.
Executive order returning thanks to the Ohio
Volunteers for one hundred days:--
EXECUTIVE MANSION, WASHINGTON CITY, September 10,
1864.
The term of one hundred days for which the National
Guard of Ohio
volunteered having expired, the President directs an official
acknowledgment of their patriotism and valuable services during the recent
campaign.
The term of service of their enlistment was short, but distinguished
by
memorable events in the valley of the Shenandoah, on the Peninsula,
in
the operations of the James River, around Petersburg and Richmond,
in
the battle of Monocacy, in the intrenchments of Washington, and in
other
important service. The National Guard of Ohio performed with
alacrity
the duty of patriotic volunteers, for which they are entitled, and
are here by tendered, through the Governor of their State, the national
thanks.
The Secretary of War is directed to transmit a copy
of this order to the
Governor of Ohio, and to cause a certificate of their honorable
service to be
delivered to the officers and soldiers of the Ohio National Guard,
who recently served in the military force of the United States as
volunteers for
one hundred days.
ABRAHAM LINCOLN.
THANKS TO THE TROOPS
OF ILLINOIS.
WAR DEPARTMENT,
WASHINGTON, October 7,
1864.
To THE GOVERNOR OF ILLINOIS:
The following order has been made by the President,
and the Adjutant General is preparing certificates for the officers and soldiers of
your
State, which will be forwarded to you for distribution.
EDWIN M. STANTON, Secretary
of War,
EXECUTIVE MANSION, WASHINGTON, October 1,
1864.
Special Executive order returning thanks to
volunteers for one hun dred days, from the States of Illinois. Indiana, Iowa, and
Wisconsin:--
The term of one hundred days for which volunteers
from the States of
Indiana, Illinois, Iowa, and Wisconsin volunteered, under the call
of their
respective Governors, in the months of May and June, to aid the
recent
campaign of General Sherman, having expired, the President directs
an
official acknowledgment to be made of their patriotic service. It
was
their good fortune to render effective service in the brilliant
operations
in the Southwest, and to contribute to the victories of the national
arms
over the rebel forges in Georgia, under command of Johnston and
Hood. On
all occasions, and in every service to which they were assigned,
their duty
as patriotic volunteers was performed with alacrity and courage, for
which
they are entitled to and are hereby tendered the national thanks
through
the Governors of their respective States.
The Secretary of War is directed to transmit a copy
of this order to
the Governors of Indiana, Illinois, Iowa, and Wisconsin, and to
cause a
certificate of their honorable services to be delivered to the
officers and
soldiers of the States above named, who recently served in the
military
service of the United States as volunteers for one hundred days.
A. LINCOLN.
To one of the Ohio regiments returning through Washington and calling to serenade him, the President made a brief
speech, in which are noticeable, first, his desire to impress
upon thrum the importance of the main point involved in
the contest with the rebellion, and the duty of not allowing minor matters to blind them to this main point, and
second, that specimen of his careful and perfectly clear
way of stating a proposition, when he says, not that this
is a country in which all men are equal, but that it is one
in which "every man has a
right to be equal to
every
other man."
The speech was as follows:--
SOLDIERS:--You are about to return to your homes and your friends,
after having, as I learn, performed in camp a comparatively short
term
of duty in this great contest. I am greatly obliged to yon, and to
all
who have come forward at the call of their country. I wish it might
be
more generally and universally understood what the country is now
engaged in. We have, as all will agree, a free government, where
every
man has a right to be equal with every other man. In this great
struggle,
this form of government and every form of human right is endangered
if our enemies succeed. There is more involved in this contest than
is
realized by every one. There is involved in this struggle, the
question
whether your children and my children shall enjoy the privileges we
have enjoyed. I say this, in order to impress upon you, if you are
not
already so impressed, that no small matter should divert us from our
great purpose.
There may be
some inequalities in the practical application of our
system. It is fair that each man shall pay taxes in exact proportion
to
the value of his property; but if we should wait, before collecting
a tax,
to adjust the taxes upon each man in exact proportion with every
other
man, we should never collect any tax at all. There may be mistakes
made sometimes; things may be done wrong, while the officers of the
Government do all they can to prevent mistakes. But I beg of you, as
citizens of this great Republic, not to let your minds be carried
off from
the great work we have before us. This struggle is too large for you
to
be diverted from it by any small matter. When you return to your
homes, rise up to the height of a generation of men worthy of a free
government, and we will carry out the great work we have commenced.
I return to you my sincere thanks, soldiers, for the honor you have
done
me this afternoon.
To another Ohio regiment he spoke as follows:--
SOLDIERS:--I
suppose you are going home to see your families and
friends. For the services you have done in this great struggle in
which
we are engaged, I present you sincere thanks for myself and the
country.
I almost always feel inclined, when I say any thing
to soldiers, to impress
upon them, in a few brief remarks, the importance of success in this
contest.
It is not merely for the day, but for all time to come, that we
should perpetuate for our children's children that great and free government
which
we have enjoyed all our lives. I beg you to remember this, not
merely
for my sake, but for yours. I happen, temporarily, to occupy this
big
White House. I am a living witness that any one of your children may
look to come here as my father's child has. It is in order that each
one
of you may have, through this free government which we have enjoyed,
an open field, and a fair chance for your industry, enterprise, and
intelligence; that you may all have equal privileges in the race of life,
with
all its desirable human aspirations--it is for this that the
struggle should
be maintained, that we may not lose our birthrights--not only for
one,
but for two or three years, if necessary. The nation is worth
fighting
for, to secure such an inestimable jewel.
The premonitory symptoms of the result of the Presidential contest were seen in the State elections by which
it was preceded.
In September Vermont led off with a largely increased
Union majorty, and Maine followed her a week after,
showing also a proportionate increase in the majority
with which that State had sustained the Administration.
But the October elections in Ohio, Indiana, and Pennsylvania indicated yet more clearly what was to be the result in
November. The two former States gave heavy
majorities for the Union ticket on the home vote. In
fact, in Indiana the soldiers were not allowed to vote at
all. Governor Morton, who was a candidate for re-election, had made a splendid canvass, speaking with great
effect all over the State. One matter which doubtless
aided him materially, was the discovery of a plot on the
part of leading members of the Democratic party in the
Northwest to raise a revolt in that section of the country, to release the rebel prisoners, and by arming them,
to make a powerful diversion in favor of the rebels. The
election following close upon this exposure, Indiana reelected Governor Morton by a large majority, in spite of
the absence of many of her loyal sons ill the field.
In Pennsylvania the result upon the home vote was
close, but with the soldiers' votes the Union ticket carried the State by about twelve thousand majority.
A victory was won, also, in Maryland for freedom, by
the adoption, though by a close vote, of the new Free
State Constitution. The heavy majorities in its favor,
which were given by Baltimore and the more loyal sections of the State, were overborne by the votes of the
southern and western counties, but the votes of the
soldiers were almost unanimous in favor of the Constitution, and Maryland took her place as a State whose
freedom was insured.
Mr. Lincoln took great interest in the success of this
Constitution. The following is a letter which he wrote
to a meeting of its friends in Baltimore, before the election:--
EXECUTIVE MANSION, WASHINGTON, October 18.
Hon. HENRY W.
HOFFMAN:
MY DEAR SIR:--A convention of Maryland has formed a
new Constitution for the State; a public meeting is called for this evening,
at Baltimore, to aid in securing its ratification, and you ask a word from
me for
the occasion. I presume the only feature of the instrument about
which
there is serious controversy, is that which provides for the
extinction of
slavery.
It needs not to be a secret, and I presume it is no
secret, that I wish
success to this provision. I desire it on every consideration. I
wish to see all men free. I wish the national prosperity of the
already
free, which I feel sure the extinction of slavery would bring. I
wish to
see in progress of disappearing that only thing which could bring
this
nation to civil war. I attempt no argument. Argument upon the
question
is already exhausted by the abler, better informed and more
immediately
interested sons of Maryland herself. I only add, that I shall be
gratified
exceedingly if the good people of the State shall by their votes
ratify the
new Constitution.
After the result of the election was known, the President made the following speech at a serenade given to
him by the loyal Marylanders, in honor of the adoption
of the Constitution:--
FRIENDS AND
FELLOW-CITIZENS:--I am notified that this is a compliment
paid me by the loyal Marylanders resident in this District. I infer
that
the adoption of the new Constitution for the State furnishes the
occasion,
and that in your view the extirpation of slavery constitutes the
chief
merit of the new Constitution. Most heartily do I congratulate you,
and
Maryland, and the nation, and the world, upon this event. I regret
that
it did not occur two years sooner, which, I am sure, would have
saved the
nation more money than would have met all the private loss incident
to
the measure; but it has come at last, and I sincerely hope its
friends
may fully realize all their anticipations of good from it, and that
its
opponents may by its effects be agreeably and profitably
disappointed.
A word upon another subject. Something said by the
Secretary of
State in his recent speech at Auburn, has been construed by some
into a
threat, that if I shall be beaten at the election, I will, between
then and
the end of my constitutional term, do what I may be able to ruin the
Government.
Others regard the fact that the Chicago Convention
adjourned, not sine
die, but to meet again, if called to do so by a particular
individual, as
the intimation of a purpose that if their nominee shall be elected
he will
at once seize control of the Government. I hope the good people will
permit themselves to suffer no uneasiness on either point. I am
strug gling to maintain the Government, not to overthrow it. I am
struggling
especially to prevent others from overthrowing it. I therefore say
that if I live, I shall remain President until the 4th of next
March,
and that whoever shall be constitutionally elected, in November,
shall be duly installed as President on the 4th of March, and in the
inter val I shall do my utmost that whoever is to hold the helm for the
next
voyage shall start with the best possible chance of saving the ship.
This
is due to the people, both on principle and under the Constitution.
Their will, constitutionally expressed, is the ultimate law for all.
If they should deliberately resolve to have immediate peace, even at
the loss of
their country and their liberties, I know not the power or the right
to
resist them. It is their own business, and they must do as they
please
with their own. I believe, however, they are still resolved to
preserve
their country and their liberties; and in this, in office or out of
it, I am re solved to stand by them. I may add, that in this purpose to save the
country and its liberties, no classes of people seem so nearly
unanimous
as the soldiers in the field and the sailors afloat. Do they not
have the
hardest of it? Who should quail while they do not? God bless the
sol diers and seamen, with all their brave commanders.
The latter part of this speech was called forth by a current misrepresentation of a speech made by Secretary Seward at Auburn, on the 5th of September. The Secretary
had alluded to the declaration of the Chicago Convention
in favor of an immediate cessation of hostilities, and the
inevitable tendency of the success of the ticket nominated
upon that platform to paralyze the efforts of the Government to put down the rebellion by force of arms; and
he asked, if such a thing should happen, "who could
vouch for the safety of the country against the rebels,
during the interval which must elapse before the new
Administration can constitutionally come into power?"
This was distorted into a threat that if the Democratic
candidate should be elected, the Administration would
take means to retain by usurpation the power which
should of right be handed over to him. And the charge
was repeated so persistently, that the President at length
felt called upon to notice it as he did.
The result of the October elections had practically
determined the result in November. But, as the time
drew near, the atmosphere seemed full of turbulent and
threatening elements. Loud and angry charges of fraud
in the October elections were made by the Opposition, but
were not sustained; and they were succeeded by yet
louder charges from the other side of an attempted fraud
in the soldiers' votes of the State of New York, which
were followed up by proof. Some of the Democratic
agents were convicted of these attempted frauds, and,
after trial and conviction by a military commission, they
were sentenced to a, heavy imprisonment.
The rebels used all means in their power to aid the
party from whose success they anticipated so much advantage. Hood's movement, it was hoped, would have
a political influence upon the election; and Early's advance was spoken of in Southern journals as a means of
assisting the counting of the ballots in Pennsylvania.
Along the Northern border, too, the rebel agents, sent
thither on "detached service" by the Rebel Government,
were active, in movements intended to terrify and harass
the people. On the 19th of October, a party of them
made a raid into St. Albans, Vermont, robbing the banks
there, and making their escape across the lines into Canada with their plunder, having killed one of the citizens
in their attack. Pursuit was made, and several of
the marauders were arrested in Canada. Proceedings
were commenced to procure their extradition, which were
not, however, brought to a close before the election. The
Government received information that this affair was but
one of a projected series, and that similar attempts would
be made all along the frontier. More than this, there
were threats, followed by actual attempts, to set fire to
the principal Northern cities, and there were not wanting
some signs of an inclination to renew the scenes of the
riots of the year before.
A very grave sensation was produced by the publication of a report of Judge Advocate-General Holt, giving
conclusive proof of the existence of an organized secret
association at the North, controlled by prominent men in
the Democratic party, whose objects were the overthrow,
by revolution, of the Administration, in the interest of the
rebellion. Some of the leaders were arrested and tried.
The Democratic presses had sneered at the whole affair as
one which was got up by the Government for political
effect. But when one of their leaders, being on parole
as he was being tried, ran away rather than meet the result, people began to be sensible of the danger they had
escaped.
So rife were threats of a revolution at the North, and
especially in New York City, if Mr. Lincoln were reelected, that the
Government sent a body of veterans
from the Army of the James, under General Butler, to
that city for purposes of precaution. But, fortunately,
in New York, as everywhere else, so quiet an election
was never known, nor was there ever one more utterly
free from complaints of fraud. Certainly, none so decisive was ever held in this country. Of all the States
which voted on that day, General McClellan carried
but three--New Jersey, Delaware, and Kentucky-while Mr. Lincoln received the votes of all the New
England States, of New York and Pennsylvania, of all
the Western States, of West Virginia, Tennessee, Louisiana, and Arkansas, and of the new State of Nevada,
which was, on the 31st of October, admitted into the
Union by the following proclamation:--
Whereas, The Congress of the United States
passed an act, which was
approved on the 21st day of March last, entitled, "An Act to enable
the
People of Nevada to form a Constitution and State Government," and
for
the admission of such State into the Union on an equal footing with
the
original States; and
Whereas, The said Constitution and State
Government have been formed
pursuant to the condition prescribed by the fifth section of the act
of Congress aforesaid, and the certificate required by the said act, and
also a
copy of the Constitution and ordinances have been submitted to the
President of the United States:
Now, therefore, be it known, that I, Abraham
Lincoln, President of
the United States, in accordance with the duty imposed upon me by
the
act of Congress aforesaid, do hereby declare and proclaim that the
said
State of Nevada is admitted into the Union on an equal footing with
the
original States.
In witness whereof, I have hereunto set my hand and
caused the seal
of the United States to be affixed.
Done at the City of Washington, this
thirty-first day of October, in the year of our Lord one
thousand eight hundred and sixty-four,
and of the independence of the United States the
eighty-ninth. |
[L. S.] |
(Signed) |
ABRAHAM LINCOLN. |
By the President:
Wm. H. Seward, Secretary
of State.
The vote at that election was very large everywhere,
and Mr. Lincoln received a popular majority of over four
hundred thousand votes--a larger majority than was ever
received by any other President.
The feeling which was uppermost in the President's
heart at the result of the election was joy over its effects
upon the cause. He expressed this sentiment in some remarks which he made, when serenaded by a club of Pennsylvanians, at a late hour on the night of the election. His
speech was as follows:--
FRIENDS AND
FELLOW-CITIZEN:--Even before I had been informed by
you that this compliment was paid to me by loyal citizens of
Pennsylvania, friendly to me, I had inferred that you were that portion of my
countrymen who think that the best interests of the nation are to be
sub served by the support of the present Administration. I do not
pretend
to say that you who think so embrace all the patriotism and loyalty
of
the country. But I do believe, and I trust without personal
interest,
that the welfare of the country does require that such support and
indorsement be given. I earnestly believe that the consequence of this
day's work, if it be as you assure me, and as now seems probable,
will be
to the lasting advantage, if not to the very salvation of the
country. I
cannot at this hour say what has been the result of the election;
but what ever it may have been, I have no desire to modify this opinion, that
all
who have labored to-day in behalf of the Union organization have
wrought for the best interests of their country and the world, not
only
for the present, but for all future ages. I am thankful to God for
this
approval of the people. But, while deeply grateful for this mark of
their
confidence in me, if I know my heart, my gratitude is free from any
taint
of personal triumph. I do not impugn the motives of any one opposed
to
me. It is no pleasure to me to triumph over any one, but I give
thanks
to the Almighty for this evidence of the people's resolution to
stand by
free government and the rights of humanity.
The telegraph brought certain news of the result within a few hours. On the night of November 10th, the
various Lincoln and Johnson Clubs of the District went
to the White House to serenade the President, to whom
he spoke as follows:--
It has long
been a grave question whether any Government, not too
strong for the liberties of its people, can be strong enough to
maintain its
existence in great emergencies. On this point the present rebellion
brought our Government to a severe test, and a Presidential election
occurring in a regular course during the rebellion, added not a
little to the
train.
If the loyal
people united were put to the utmost of their strength by
the rebellion, must they not fail when divided and partially
paralyzed by
a political war among themselves? But the election was a necessity.
We cannot have free government without elections; and if the
rebellion
could force us to forego or postpone a national election, it might
fairly
claim to have already conquered and ruined us. The strife of the
election is but human nature practically applied to the facts of the
case.
What has occurred in this case must ever recur in similar cases.
Human
nature will not change. In any future great national trial, compared
with the men of this, we will have as weak and as strong, as silly
and as
wise, as bad and as good. Let us, therefore, study the incidents of
this
as philosophy to learn wisdom from, and none of them as wrongs to be
revenged.
But the election, along with its incidental and
undesirable strife, has
done good, too. It has demonstrated that a people's government can
sustain a national election in the midst of a great civil war. Until
now,
it has not been known to the world that this was a possibility. It
shows,
also, how sound and how strong we still are. It shows that even
among
the candidates of the same party, he who is most devoted to the
Union
and most opposed to treason can receive most of the people's votes.
It
shows, also, to the extent yet known, that we have more men now than
we had when the war began. Gold is good in its place; but living,
brave, and patriotic men are better than gold.
But the rebellion continues, and, now that the
election is over, may
not all have a common interest to reunite in a common effort to save
our
common country? For my own part, I have striven and shall strive to
avoid placing any obstacle in the way. So long as I have been here,
I
have not willingly planted a thorn in any man's bosom. While I am
duly sensible to the high compliment of a re-election, and duly
grateful,
as I trust, to Almighty God, for having directed my countrymen to a
right conclusion, as I think, for their good, it adds nothing to my
satisfaction that any other man may be disappointed by the result.
May I ask those who have not differed with me to
join with me in this
same spirit towards those who have? And now, let me close by asking
three hearty cheers for our brave soldiers and seamen, and their
gallant
and skilful commanders.
But though the President rejoiced over the result
mainly because of its public bearing on the welfare of
the country, he was by no means insensible to the personal confidence in himself which it exhibited. This feeling he expressed in a speech which he made to the State
Committee of Maryland, who waited on him to congratulate him upon the trust.
The Chairman had remarked that they felt under deep
obligations to him because, by the exercise of rare discretion on his part, Maryland to-day occupied the proud
position of a free State.
The President
said that he would not attempt to conceal his gratification with the result of the election. He had exercised his best
judgment
for the good of the whole country, and to have the seal of
approbation
placed upon his course was exceedingly grateful to his feelings.
Believing the policy he had pursued was the best
and the only one
which could save the country, he repeated what he had said before,
that
he indulged in no feeling of triumph over any one who had thought or
acted differently from himself. He had no such feeling towards any
living man. He thought the adoption of a Free State Constitution for
Maryland was "a big thing," and a victory for right and worth a
great
deal more than the part of Maryland in the Presidential election,
although
of the latter he thought well. In conclusion, he repeated what he
had
said before: namely, that those who differed from and opposed us,
will
yet see that defeat was better for their own good than if they had
been
successful.
This same sense of personal gratitude found expression
in the following letter which he wrote to Deacon John
Phillips, of Stourbridge, Massachusetts, who, though a
hundred and four years old, attended the polls to cast
his vote for Mr. Lincoln:--
EXECUTIVE MANSON, WASHINGTON, November 21,
1864.
MY DEAR SIR:--I have heard of the incident at the
polls in your town,
in which you acted so honorable a part, and I take the liberty of
writing
to you to express my personal gratitude for the compliment paid me
by
the suffrage of a citizen so venerable.
The example of such devotion to civic duties in one
whose days have
already been extended an average lifetime beyond the Psalmist's
limit,
cannot but be valuable and fruitful. It is not for myself only, but
for
the country which you have in your sphere served so long and so
well,
that I thank you. Your friend and servant,
ABRAHAM LINCOLN.
Deacon JOHN
PHILLIPS.
We publish here, as it was written on the same day, the
following graceful letter addressed by the President to
Mrs. Bixby, a resident of Boston, who had lost five sons
in the war, and whose sixth was lying severely wounded
at the time in the hospital:--
EXECUTIVE MANSION, WASHINGTON, November 21,
1864.
DEAR MADAM:--I have been shown in the files of the
War Department
a statement of the Adjutant-General of Massachusetts, that you are
the
mother of five sons who have died gloriously on the field of battle.
I
feel how weak and fruitless must be any words of mine which should
attempt to beguile you from the grief of a loss so overwhelming. But
I
cannot refrain from tendering to you the consolation that may be
found
in the thanks of the Republic they died to save. I pray that our
Heavenly
Father may assuage the anguish of your bereavement, and leave you
only
the cherished memory of the loved and lost, and the solemn pride
that
must be yours to have laid so costly a sacrifice upon the altar of
freedom.
Yours, very sincerely and
respectfully,
ABRAHAM LINCOLN.
To Mrs.
BIXBY, Boston, Massachusetts.
This letter, addressed to one conspicuous among the
thousands who had laid "costly sacrifices upon the altar
of Freedom," touched the hearts of all, and strengthened
the feelings of love which the great body of the people
were coming to cherish for the man whom Providence
had made their ruler.
Prominent among the sentiments which ruled the heart
and life of Mr. Lincoln, was that reverential sense of dependence upon an Almighty Providence, which finds
strong expression in the following letter which he addressed to Mrs. Eliza P. Gurney, an American lady resident in London, and wife of a wealthy Quaker banker
of that city:--
MY ESTEEMED
FRIEND:--I have not forgotten, probably never shall
forget, the very impressive occasion when yourself and friends
visited me
on a Sabbath forenoon, two years ago; nor had your kind letter,
written
nearly a year later, ever been forgotten. In all it has been your
purpose
to strengthen my reliance in God. I am much indebted to the good
Christian people of the country for their constant prayer and
consolation,
and to no one of them more than to yourself. The purposes of the Al mighty are perfect and must prevail, though we erring mortals may
fail
to accurately perceive them in advance. We hoped for a happy termination of this terrible war long before this, but God knows best, and
has
ruled otherwise. We shall yet acknowledge His wisdom and our own
errors therein. Meanwhile we must work earnestly in the best lights
He gives us, trusting that so working still conduces to the great
ends He
ordains. Surely, He intends some great good to follow this mighty
convulsion, which no mortal could make, and no mortal could stay.
Your
people--the Friends--have had, and are having, very great trials.
On principle and faith opposed to both war and oppression, they can
only
practically oppose oppression by war. In this hard dilemma, some
have
chosen one horn and some the other. For those appealing to me on
conscientious grounds, I have done and shall do the best I could and
can in
my own conscience under my oath to the law. That you believe this, I
doubt not, and believing it, I shall still receive for our country
and my self your earnest prayers to our Father in Heaven.
Your sincere friend,
A. LINCOLN.
This sense of religious reliance upon Providence, evident in all his acts, as well as in his expressions, and a
feeling of the integrity and purity of purpose which pervaded all his acts, had won for Mr. Lincoln the cordial
support of the various Christian churches of the country,
and he had good reason, therefore, for thus expressing
his indebtedness to the "Christian people of the land for
their constant prayer and consolation." Though not a
member of any church or sect, he never neglected a
proper occasion for declaring his faith in those great
principles on which all Christian churches and sects are
built.
When a committee of colored men from Baltimore came
to him to present him an elegant copy of the Bible, he
made the following brief speech in answer to their address:--
I can only
say now, as I have often said before, it has always been a
sentiment with me, that all mankind should be free. So far as I have
been able, so far as came within my sphere, I have always acted as I
believed was just and right, and done all I could for the good of
mankind.
I have, in letters sent forth from this office, expressed myself
better than
I can now.
In regard to the great Book, I have only to say it
is the best gift which
God has ever given to man. All the good from the Saviour of the
world
is communicated to us through this Book. But for that Book, we could
not
know right from wrong. All those things desirable to man are
contained
in it. I return you sincere thanks for this very elegant copy of
this great
Book of God which you present.
All knew that Mr. Lincoln was a man of thorough
honesty of speech, and his whole life vindicated his assertion that he
had acted as he believed was just and right, and
had done all he could for the good of mankind. It was not
strange, therefore, that the churches of the country gathered around such a leader of such a cause. When the
General Conference of the Methodist Church met in May,
1864, they adopted a series of resolutions, expressing the
loyalty of that church, and their sympathy with him.
These resolutions were presented to the President, who
responded to the accompanying address as follows:--
GENTLEMEN:--In response to your address, allow me to attest the
accuracy of its historical statements, indorse the sentiments it
expresses,
and thank you in the nation's name for the sure promise it gives.
Nobly
sustained, as the Government has been, by all the churches, I would
utter nothing which might in the least appear invidious against any.
Yet without this, it may fairly be said, that the Methodist
Episcopal
Church, not less devoted than the best, is by its greatest numbers
the
most important of all. It is no fault in others that the Methodist
Church
sends more soldiers to the field, more nurses to the hospitals, and
more
prayers to Heaven than any other. God bless the Methodist Church.
Bless all the churches; and blessed be God, who in this our great
trial
giveth us the churches.
Similar action was also taken by the Baptist Church,
and to their delegation, on the presentation of the resolutions, the President spoke as follows:--
In the
present very responsible position in which I am engaged, I have
had great cause of gratitude for the support so unanimously given by
all
Christian denominations of the country. I have had occasion so frequently to respond to something like this assemblage, that I have
said all I
had to say. This particular body is, in all respects, as respectable
as any
that have been presented to me. The resolutions I have merely heard
read, and I therefore beg to be allowed an opportunity to make a
short
response in writing.
These expressions were not confined to the religious
bodies; they came to the President from all quarters.
His sense of this sympathy on the part of those engaged
in the educational interest was expressed in a letter which
he wrote on learning that Princeton College had given
him the degree of LL.D. The letter was as follows:--
EXECUTIVE MANSION, WASHINGTON, December 27,
1864.
MY DEAR SIR:--I have the honor to acknowledge the
reception of your
note of the 20th of December, conveying the announcement that the
Trustees of the College of New Jersey had conferred upon me the degree
of
Doctor of Laws.
The assurance conveyed by this high compliment,
that the course of
the Government which I represent has received the approval of a body
of
gentlemen of such character and intelligence, in this time of public
trial,
most grateful to me.
Thoughtful men must feel that the fate of
civilization upon this continent is involved in the issue of our contest. Among the most
gratifying
proofs of this conviction is the hearty devotion everywhere
exhibited by
our schools and colleges to the national cause.
I am most thankful if my labors have seemed to
conduct to the
of those institutions, under which alone we can expect good
government, and in its train sound learning, and the progress of the
liberal arts.
I am, sir, very truly, your obedient
servant,
A. LINCOLN.
Dr. JOHN MACLEAN.
It was with no ordinary interest that the "good Christian people" of the North had in the political campaign.
And it was with satisfaction that they saw the triumph
of the cause, which was so dear to their hearts, secured
by the re-election of a man so true, so pure, so honest,
so kindly, so thoroughly Christian in the true sense of
the word, as President Lincoln. |