|
Docetists |
Ebionites |
Arians |
Appollinarians |
Nestorians |
Eutychians |
Proponents |
Basilides
Valentinus
Patripassians
Sabellians |
Judaizers |
Arius, presbyter of Alexandria
Origen? |
Appollinarius, bishop of Laodicea
Justin Martyr |
Represented by Nestorius, bishop
of Constantinople |
Represented by Eutychius
Theodosius II |
Time |
Late 1st century |
2nd century |
4th century |
4th century |
5th century |
5th century |
Denial |
Genuine humanity |
Genuine deity |
Genuine deity |
Completeness of humanity |
Unity of persons |
Distinction of natures |
Explanation |
Jesus appeared human but was
really divine |
Christ had the Spirit after his
baptism; he was not preexistent |
Christ was the first and highest
created being |
The divine Logos took the place
of the human mind |
Union was moral, not
organic-thus two persons. The human was completely controlled by
the divine |
Monophysitist; the human nature
was swallowed by the divine to create a new third nature- a
tertium quid |
Condemned |
No official condemnation |
No official condemnation |
Council of Nicea, A.D. 325 |
Council of Antioch, A.D. 378
Council of Constantinople, A.D.
381 |
Synod of Ephesus, A.D. 431 |
Council of Chalcedon, A.D. 451 |
Associated with |
Evil of Material world.
Marcion, Gnostics |
Legalism |
Generation = creation |
Logos=reason in all people |
“Word-flesh” not “word-man”
Christology |
Concern for the unity and
divinity of Christ |
Argument against |
If Christ was not human He could
not redeem humanity (Heb. 2:14; I Jn. 4:1-3) |
Only a divine Christ is worthy
of worship (Jn. 1:1; 20:28; Heb. 13:8) |
Only a divine Christ is worthy
of worship; this view tends toward polytheism. Only a divine
Christ can save (Phil. 2:6; Rev. 1:8) |
If Christ did not have a human
mind, he would not be truly human (Heb. 2:14; I Jn. 4:1-3) |
If the death of Jesus was the
act of a human person, not of God, it could not be efficacious
(Rev. 1:12-18) |
If Christ was neither a man nor
God, he could not redeem as man or God (Phil. 2:6) |
Major Opponents |
Irenaeus
Hippolytus |
Irenaeus
Hippolytus
Origen
Eusebius |
Athanasius
Ossius |
Vitalis
Pope Damascus
Basil
Theodosius
Gregory of Nazianzen
Gregory of Nyssa |
Cyril of Alexandria |
Flavian of Constantinople
Pope Leo
Theodoret
Eusebius of Dorylaeum |