These papers will be
rudimentary. Their purpose is to
mark out the lines of the
evidence, within the field
traversed, so as to facilitate
the work of the student who
wishes to examine the evidence
for himself. In the present
state of the questions involved,
no student can reach
satisfactory conclusions, except
by an original study of the
evidence.
Of course, I present the
evidence from the point of view
I myself have reached ; but what
I mean to do is to present the
evidence, and not merely the
point of view. It is by design
that I repeat this word evidence
seven times, in these few
sentences. What we have to do is
to examine the evidence; and
this is a different thing from
accepting some traditional
opinion, either old or new, and
is equally a different thing
from reading all sides, and then
guessing out an opinion by the
law of averages.
THE SEVENTY YEARS OF THE EXILE.1
The limits of the seventy
years.—The seventy years so
familiarly spoken of, following
Jer. 25:11-12; 29:10, may
perhaps be regarded as a round
number, rather than an exact
number; though there are at
least three ways in which it can
be counted as exact. It is just
seventy years, counting one of
the terminal years, from the
death of Josiah, B. C. 608, to
the first year of Cyrus, 538 B.
C.; it is just seventy, counting
both the terminal years, from
the deportation of Daniel, 605
B. C., to the first year of
Cyrus, reckoned as 536 B. C.; it
is just seventy years, counting
one terminal year, from the
burning of the temple, B. C.,
586, to the completing of
Zerubbabel's temple, B. C. 516.
We have no need to trouble
ourselves to decide between
these possible interpretations
of the phrase.
The sources of the history.—The
Biblical sources of information
for the history of the period
are the concluding chapters of 2
Kings and 2 Chronicles; the
books of Jeremiah and
Lamentations; the books of
Ezekiel and Daniel; some psalms,
Ps. 137, for example; the
genealogies in I Chronicles; and
incidental notices elsewhere.
Some of these books will be
further noticed hereafter. The
student who really cares to know
the history for himself should
read these books carefully
enough so that he will be able
to make a reasonably full and
correct statement of their
contents. He cannot master the
historical information contained
in them at any cheaper rate than
this.
Ancient extra-biblical sources
of information for the time we
are considering are the writings
of Berosus,2
and of other oriental
historians, preserved by
Josephus and others (see
especially Josephus
Cont. Apion, I.
19-21, and Ant. X. xi.
1); and occasional items in the
inscriptions of the Babylonian
and Persian kings. The Greek
historians, Herodotus, B.C. 484
to about 400, Ctesias, B. C. 398
and earlier, and Xenophon, about
B. C. 444-357, wrote popular
histories, including these
times, but without that careful
regard for facts that
characterizes the oriental
historians. Josephus, about A.
D. 100, repeats the accounts
given in the Bible. Both he and
the Greek historians give some
additional statements of fact
that are worth noting.
The chronology.—The dates
for this and the subsequent
times can be best studied by
referring them to the scheme
known as the canon of Ptolemy.
Whatever be true of certain
views of history implied in this
canon, no one disputes its
correctness as a scheme for
giving names to the years in
their succession. By this canon,
the years for the time now under
consideration are named as
follows:
B. C. 625-605 are the 21
years of Nabopolassar.
B. C. 604-562 are the 43
years of Nebuchadnezzar.
B. C. 561-560 are the 2
years of Evil-merodach.
B. C. 559-556 are the 4
years of Neriglissar.
B. C. 555-539 are the 17
years of Nabonidus.
B. C. 538-530 are the 9
years of Cyrus.
In this table, the year that is
called the first year of any
king is ordinarily that which
begins with the new moon of the
spring equinox next after he
comes to the throne. It is
convenient to adopt this mode of
notation, because it is that in
which most dates are given, in
ancient writings, and we thus
avoid confusion. But in
following it we need to keep in
mind that the actual accession
of a king commonly occurred
during the year previous to that
which is called his first year,
and that events occurring
between the first of January and
the new moon of the spring
equinox belong, by this style,
to the concluding months of the
old year, and not to the opening
months of the new year. For such
events, the year of the
Christian era is one year later,
by our usual style of reckoning,
than it is if reckoned in the
ancient style.
The historicity of the
accounts.—There is no
important dispute in regard to
the Biblical sources, except in
the case of the book of Daniel.
This has commonly been regarded
as historical, and still is
commonly so regarded; but many
scholars now hold that it is
principally, or at least
largely, fiction. The only
reasons urged for this view are
the character of the events
recorded, and the form in which
they are recorded. Since this is
the case, the proper way for the
student to do is to accept the
facts provisionally, until he
has studied them and compared
them with the contemporary
facts; when he has done this,
and not till then, he will be in
position to judge them, with
reference to final acceptance or
rejection.
The dated events.—To
obtain a distinct idea of this
period, one needs to get clearly
in mind the principal dated
events in it. The following list
of these, in the earlier part of
it, is abridged from the
thirty-seventh and the fortieth
Inductive Studies, in the Old
Testament Student for June,
1888:
-
608 B. C. Death of Josiah,
king of Judah, in battle
with Necho of Egypt. Not far
from the same date (a little
earlier, according to
Josephus Ant. X. v.
1; but cf. 2 Kgs. 23:29),
the final overthrow of
Nineveh by the Medes and
Nabopolassar, king of
Babylon; and the marriage of
Nebuchadnezzar, son of
Nabopolassar, to the
daughter of the Median king.
-
607 B. C. 1st year of
Jehoiakim, 2 Kgs. 23:34; 2
Chron. 36:5.
-
607-605 B. C. Certain
prophecies of Urijah and of
Jeremiah, Jer. chaps. 26 and
7-10. Successful campaigns
of Nebuchadnezzar, sent by
Nabopolassar against Egypt,
Coelosyria, and Phoenicia,
Berosus in Jos. Cont.
Apion, I. 19.
-
605 B. C. 3d year of
Jehoiakim. 21st year of
Nabopolassar. Accession of
Nebuchadnezzar, who hurried
to Babylon for that purpose,
followed later by his
Jewish, Syrian, Phoenician,
and other captives, Berosus
as above. Daniel and his
companions carried away, and
Nebuchadnezzar's civil
service training school
formed, Dan. 1:1-16.
-
604 B. C. 4th year of
Jehoiakim, and 1st of
Nebuchadnezzar, Jer. 46:2 ;
25:1. The decisive battle of
Carchemish, 46:2. Jeremiah
prophesying against the
nations, and against Israel,
46:1-49:33; 25:1-38,
especially ver. 13. Baruch
writing Jeremiah's
prophecies, Jer. 45; 36:1-8.
-
603 B. C. 5th of Jehoiakim,
and 2d of Nebuchadnezzar.
Baruch's second roll, Jer.
36:9-32. Daniel and his
companions complete their
three years' training, and
Daniel explains the king's
dream, Dan. 1:5, 16-21;
2:1-49.
-
598 B. C. 7th of
Nebuchadnezzar. 3023 persons
deported, Jer. 52:28.
Possibly, siege of Tyre
begun, Jos. Cont. Ap.
I. 21.
-
597 B. C. 11th of Jehoiakim,
and 8th of Nebuchadnezzar.
Jehoiakim killed. Short
reign of Jehoiachin, also
called Coniah, and Jeconiah.
The great deportation to
Babylon. Accession of
Zedekiah. 2 Kgs. 24:6-16; 2
Chron. 36:9-10; Jer.
36:30-31; 22:18-30; 24:1,
etc.
-
596-594 B. C. Jews in
Babylonia, Judah, and Egypt,
Jer. 24. Jeremiah's letter
to the Babylonian Jews, and
incidents connected with it,
Jer. 29. His prophecy
concerning Elam, 49:34-39.
-
593 B. C. 4th of Zedekiah.
Hananiah and Jeremiah, Jer.
27 and 28. Zedekiah's
special act of homage, Jer.
51:59-64. Jeremiah
prophesying against Babylon,
Jer. 5o and 51.
-
592 B. C. 5th of Zedekiah.
Ezekiel prophesying among
the exiles by Chebar, Ezek.
1:2 and chaps. 1-7.3
-
591 B. C., last half. 6th of
Zedekiah. Ezekiel
prophesying among the exiles
in regard to the prevalent
idolatry and the approaching
fate of Jerusalem, chaps.
8-19. Daniel recognized as
an especially great man,
Ezek. 14:14. Zedekiah's
perjury and rebellion, Ezek.
17:2-21; 2 Kgs. 24:19-20; 2
Chron. 36:12-13a.
-
590 B. C. 7th of Zedekiah,
Ezek. 20:1 sq. Ezekiel
prophesies ultimate
restoration, but for the
present, rebuke and
downfall.
-
588 B. C. 9th of Zedekiah.
Jerusalem invested, 10th day
of 10th month, say in
January B. C. 587, Ezek.
24:1 sq.; 2 Kgs. 25:1; Jer.
52:4; 39:1. Jeremiah advises
against resistance, and his
services are afterward
recognized by
Nebuchadnezzar, Jer. 21;
39:11-14; 40:1-5, etc.
Ezekiel's wife dies, an
emblem of the hopelessness
of the case of Jerusalem; he
prophesies against Judah,
Moab, Ammon, Edom,
Philistia, and the
Cherethites, Ezek. chaps.
24-25
-
587 B. C. 10th of Zedekiah,
and 18th of Nebuchadnezzar.
Interval of siege, owing to
Egyptian interference; hard
times for Jeremiah, Jer. 37.
The three Hebrew men and the
fiery furnace, Dan. 3,
according to Septuagint of
Dan. 3:1. In the 10th month,
Ezekiel denounces Egypt for
being a staff of reed to
Judah, and threatens forty
years' desolation, Ezek.
29:1, 6, 11-15 sq.
Jeremiah's land purchase,
Jer. 32. 832 persons
deported, Jer. 52:29.
-
586 B. C. 11th of Zedekiah,
and 19th of Nebuchadnezzar.
Ezekiel prophesies against
Pharaoh, first month;
Jehovah has broken one of
Pharaoh's arms, and will
break both, Ezek. 30:20.
Third month, he prophesies
again concerning Pharaoh,
comparing him to the
Assyrian, 31:. First day of
same month he prophesies
against Tyre, for exulting
in the downfall of
Jerusalem, 26:1 sq. Fourth
and fifth months, capture of
Jerusalem and burning of
temple, 2 Kgs. 25:3-21 ; 2
Chron. 36:18-20; Jer.
52:6-27; 39:4-10o. Gedaliah
made governor, and
assassinated in the seventh
month, 2 Kgs. 25:22-25; Jer.
40:5-41:o. Flight of the
people to Egypt, and
incidents there, 2 Kgs.
25:26; Jer. 41:11-44:30.
-
586-570 B. C. Within this
time, the termination of the
13 years' siege of Tyre, by
Nebuchadnezzar. See writers
cited by Josephus
Ant. X. xi. 1,
and Cont. Ap. I. 21,
and Ezek. 29:17. Within this
time, also, Nebuchadnezzar's
madness? Dan. 4.
-
585 B. C. May 28, great
solar eclipse, separating
the Median and Lydian
armies, so Herodotus and the
astronomers. Ezekiel has a
visit, in the 10th month,
from one who gives details
of the capture of Jerusalem,
Ezek. 33:21, and utters
several prophecies,
including that of the dry
bones, chap. 37. The first
and fifteenth days of the
twelfth month, he uttefrs
wailings over Egypt; Pharaoh
shall go to Sheol, where
Asshur, Elam, Meshech, Edom,
the princes of the north,
and the Zidonians await him,
Ezek. 32:1, 17 sq.
-
582 B. C. 23d of
Nebuchadnezzar. Deportation
of 745 persons from Judah,
Jer. 52:30. According to
Jos. Ant. X. ix. 7,
Nebuchadnezzar invaded
Egypt.
-
572 B. C. 25th of
Jehoiachin's exile, and 14th
after destruction of
Jerusalem, Ezek. 40:1.
Ezekiel's visions of the new
temple and holy land begin.
-
570 B. C. 27th of the exile
of Jehoiachin, Ezek. 29:17.
Egypt promised to
Nebuchadnezzar, in
recompense for his fruitless
service against Tyre.
-
568 B. C. 37th of
Nebuchadnezzar. An
expedition against Egypt
mentioned in a fragment of
an inscription of
Nebuchadnezzar.4
Whether Josephus is correct
in saying that
Nebuchadnezzar had
previously, in his 23d year,
invaded Egypt, Ant.
X. ix. 7, is a question. See
Rawlinson's Ancient
Monarchies, vol. III.,
chap. viii.
-
562 B. C. Death of
Nebuchadnezzar, and
accession of Evil-merodach.
-
561 B. C. 1st year of Evil-merodach.
At the close of the year,
that is, early in B. C. 560,
Jehoiachin released and
honored, 2 Kgs. 25:27-30;
Jer. 52:31-34.
-
559-556 B. C. The four years
of Neriglissar.
-
559-530 B. C. The 30 years
of Cyrus, king of Persia,
according to Herodotus.
Perhaps dated from his
accession to the throne of
Persia, though Herodotus is
commonly understood as
reckoning from the time of
his conquest of the Medes.
-
555-539 B. C. The 17 years
of Nabonidus.
-
550 B. C. 6th of Nabonidus.
Cyrus conquers the Medes,
and becomes their sovereign;
so one of the Cyrus
inscriptions, as' commonly
understood.5
-
? B. C. 1st year of
Belshazzar. A vision of
Daniel, chap. 7. From the
inscriptions, it is known
that Belshazzar was the son
of Nabonidus. In what sense
he reigned, or how long, is
not so well known. His reign
was within the 17 years of
Nabonidus.
-
? B. C. 3d of Belshazzar.
Another vision of Daniel,
chap. 8. This was while the
Medes and Persians together,
the former being
sub6rdinate, were pushing
west, north, and south, from
Shushan as a centre, 8:4,
20, 2, 3.
-
539 B. C. 17th of Nabonidus.
Belshazzar's feast, Dan.
chap. 5. Early in the year,
a battle, in which the
Babylonian forces were
defeated. In July, Gobryas,
the general of Cyrus,
occupied Babylon without
serious opposition; the
Greek stories in regard to
the taking of the city are
partly patched up from
events that occurred
generations earlier. In the
latter part of the year,
Cyrus assumed the
sovereignty. The book of
Daniel says that the new
emperor was Darius, the son
of Ahasuerus, of the seed of
the Medes, and that he was
about 62 years old, Dan.
5:31; 9:; 11:1; 6:28. This
Darius is not mentioned in
the inscriptions, or in the
other ancient writings. To
account for him, many
hypotheses have been
offered. Inasmuch as
Ahasuerus is the name used
in Ezra 4:6, for Cambyses,
it is possible that Darius
the son of Ahasuerus is no
other than Cyrus the son of
Cambyses himself, in which
case Dan. 6:29 (28) should
be translated " the reign of
Darius, even the reign of
Cyrus the Persian." But it
is not an absurd hypothesis
that there may have been a
Median sovereign co-regnant
with Cyrus, one or the other
being subordinate.
-
538 B. C. 1st year of Cyrus,
and 1st year of Darius the
Mede. Daniel makes
supplication for the holy
city, Dan. chap. 9, cf. i:1.
The decree for the return
under Zerubbabel, Ezra 1:1.
-
536 B. C. 3d year of Cyrus,
Dan. 10:1, cf. 1:21. A
vision of Daniel, Dan.
chaps. 10-12.
If anyone will take the trouble
to get these dated events, in
their order, clearly into his
mind, so that he can trace -the
sequences that obtain among
them, he will find himself amply
repaid. One needs to do this far
more thoroughly than is common,
even among scholars, as
preliminary to the study of
certain especially important
problems that belong to the
history of this period. The most
important of these problems is
that of the sacred literature
produced within the seventy
years. To this period the older
traditional view assigns the
completing of the books of Kings
and Jeremiah, and the books of
Lamentations, Ezekiel and
Daniel, with some of the psalms;
the present opponents of that
view dispute the claims of some
of these books, and assign to
the seventy years the
composition of certain other
parts of the Bible, notably the
opening chapters of Deuteronomy,
the closing chapters of the
same, the parts of Leviticus
which they regard as the oldest,
the last twenty-seven chapters
of Isaiah, and other portions of
the earlier prophetic books. The
next paper in this series will
consider, in outline, some of
the problems thus presented,
while the following paper will
take up the history of the
return under Zerubbabel.
|
1) In
treating of this period, I shall
necessarily repeat some things I
have already published in the
Old Testament Student—in the
Sunday School lessons, beginning
with the number for January,
1886, and in the thirty-seventh
and fortieth of the Inductive
Studies, in the number for June,
1888.
2)
Berosus was a Babylonian priest
who flourished after Alexander
the Great, and translated into
Greek the history of Babylonia,
dedicating the work to one of
the kings named Antiochus. His
work is principally known
through the fragments now found
in Josephus, and through those
preserved by Polyhistor and
Apollodorus, two writers of the
first century before Christ, as
these fragments are now found in
Eusebius and Syncellus.
Collections of the remains of
Berosus have been made by
Fabricius, in his Biblioth.
Graeca, tom, xiv.; by
Richter (Leipz. 1825); by Didot
(1848); and in Cory's Ancient
Fragments. Fuller accounts
of Berosus and his writings may
be found in the Encycl. Brit.,
in McClintock and Strong's
Biblical Cyclop., or in
other like works. Berosus is
cited in most books that treat
of Assyrian or Babylonian
matters, and the citations may
be found in those books by
index.
3) It
is evident that Ezekiel
sometimes counts the years from
the new year after Jehoiachin's
exile, that is counts them the
same as the years of Zedekiah,
cf. Ezek. 24:1 and 2 Kgs. 25:1,
or Ezek. 26:I with 2 Kgs. 25:2.
But it is also possible that
Ezekiel sometimes adopts the
different way of counting which
reckons the eleventh of
Jehoiakim as the first year of
Jehoiachin's exile, as in 2 Kgs.
25:27 cf. Ezek. 33:21. Hence it
is possible to set most of the
dates in Ezekiel a year earlier
than is done in this list,
provided there should be found a
reason for doing so.
4)
For a pretty full account of the
inscriptions of Nebuchadnezzar,
see Hebraica, Apr., 1887,
p. 164 sq. Other notices, some
of them very full and valuable,
including accounts of
inscriptions now in the
Metropolitan Museum in New York,
or in the possession of the
University of Pennsylvania, may
be found in Hebraica,
Oct., 1884, p. 118 ; Apr., 1885;
Apr., 1886, pp. 171, 173; Apr.,
1888, p. 174; Oct,, 1888, p. 74
sq. Numerous as these
inscriptions are, they relate
chiefly to building operations,
contracts, acts of worship,
etc., and contain but little
information concerning
historical events. Some of them
were until lately attributed to
an earlier Nebuchadnezzar, but
this view is now generally
abandoned. Among the most
important of them for historical
purposes, are the following:
1. The Boundary Stone
Inscription, published by
Dr. H. Hilprecht, 1883, and
in W. A. I., vol. V. Iv.-lix.
See Transactions of the
Society of Biblical
Archaeology, Apr., I884,
and Jan., 1886, and
Hebraica as above.
2. At least one inscription,
and perhaps more than one,
on the rocks bordering the
Nahr-el-kalb, or Dog river,
a little north of Beirut. It
is so mutilated that not
much of it is legible. See
Proceedings of the
Society of Bib. Arch.,
1881.
3. Three terra cotta
cylinders in the Boulak
museum, supposed to have
come from Defenneh (Tahpanhes,
Daphnai), Egypt. See Sayce
in Academy, Jan. 19,
1884, and " Defenneh," in
fourth Memoir of the
Egypt Exploration Fund, p.
51.
4. Perhaps, two large
inscriptions in Wady Brissa,
in the Lebanon, described by
Cl. Ganneau, in the Times,
Dec. 29, 1883.
These are historically
interesting, not for any
events described in them,
but because they confirm
some statements in the old
historians regarding
Nebuchadnezzar as a builder,
and because they indicate
the presence of
Nebuchadnezzar in the
Lebanon region, and in
Egypt, cf. Jer. 43:8-11, and
context.
5. A fragmentary tablet,
mentioning an expedition of
Nebuchadnezzar to Egypt in
his 37th year. See Pinches
in the Trans. of the Sac.
of Bib. Arch., vii. 2,
and Schrader, Aegypt.
Zeitschrift, 1879, and
K. A. T., 2d ed., p. 363 sq.
Brief notices of 2 and 5,
may be found in the Encyc.
Brit., "
Nebuchadnezzar," and in the
admirable article on "
Babylonia and Assyria," by
Dr. Francis Brown, in the
Encyc. Americana, I.
382.
5)
For determining the range of
events, the inscriptions of the
kings that directly followed
Nebuchadnezzar are chiefly
important because they contain
the proper names found in the
Bible, and in the Greek
historians, thus confirming the
general historicity, at least,
of these writings. Two
inscriptions of Cyrus, however,
are more definite. One is a
cylinder, mentioning his
exploits in general, his
ancestry, and his religious
policy. See Sir H. Rawlinson, in
Trans. of the Royal Asiatic
Society, N. S. xii. 70 sq.,
Jan. 1880, and Canon Rawlinson,
in the Contemporary Review
for Jan., 188o. The tablet is a
dated narrative. See Pinches, in
Trans. of the Soc. of Bib.
Arch., vii. 139 sq.
|